Best intake option in 2017?

[timmydatooth]

Originally Posted by cjd

Good thing you singled out a company that did exactly what you claim they didn't.

It's not big gains, it's small gains, and the GrimmSpeed is the only one demonstrated to work successfully without rescaling MAF - not that it doesn't benefit from a little attention. And it cleans up the engine bay a LOT - which can be rather useful.

Is it worth the money? Maybe not if you're after power, unless you are trying to squeeze the maximum amount out that a particular set of rules allows.

C

would you recommend the grimspeed CAI over just my drop in filter and silicone tube? worth the money? or pretty much will get the same gains out of both?

[timmydatooth]

Originally Posted by Lantana frs

You're not tuning your car, youre loading an existing tune into the ecu. You have the option of tweaking the tune to optimize it if you'd like but you can do that when you're comfortable with the process.

So even with the little mods that I have (invidia Q300 catback, invidia catless front pipe, drop in air filter, silicone tube) also I have an automatic by the way. The OFT will provide me with gains? I just watched an install video and it looks pretty straight forward. I just plug it up to the car, upload the stage 1 tune (thats the one I would use right?) to my car and thats all I would need to do correct?

[cjd]

Originally Posted by timmydatooth

would you recommend the grimspeed CAI over just my drop in filter and silicone tube? worth the money? or pretty much will get the same gains out of both?

Unless you want the space or want less plastic (running a Nameless header? might be a good idea!) or have other reasons for an aftermarket intake, it would be FAR down the list of mods. For most people I would say get a new silicone tube that ditches the sound generator and maybe consider trimming the snorkel (not sure if that works the same on '17+) with a drop-in filter.

I'm building to SCCA STX spec, where the gains per dollar don't necessarily ever make sense.

C

[Lantana frs]

Originally Posted by timmydatooth

So even with the little mods that I have (invidia Q300 catback, invidia catless front pipe, drop in air filter, silicone tube) also I have an automatic by the way. The OFT will provide me with gains? I just watched an install video and it looks pretty straight forward. I just plug it up to the car, upload the stage 1 tune (thats the one I would use right?) to my car and thats all I would need to do correct?

Yes

[phrosty]

Originally Posted by cjd

Good thing you singled out a company that did exactly what you claim they didn't.

They absolutely did not have this at the time of release. Did they come out with this recently?

[cjd]

Originally Posted by phrosty

They absolutely did not have this at the time of release. Did they come out with this recently?

It was there as they developed the intake, before it was released, so definitely not recent. There is even a comparison dyno in first post of the product release thread which hasn't been updated since 2014. There are comparisons on their product page if you go to their site. Probably the only thing you specified that is missing is that it's not tuned, because their intent was to release a product that did not require a tune.

More dynos, lots more information in the product development thread though.

C

[phrosty]

Originally Posted by cjd

Probably the only thing you specified that is missing is that it's not tuned

LOL, that's literally the only thing I specified!

[cjd]

Originally Posted by phrosty

LOL, that's literally the only thing I specified!

I wasn't the only one that overlooked that, but... your claim they 'fail the cheat test' is unwarranted and bogus. They're selling a product that doesn't need a tune. The dynos I expect for such a product would be... you guessed it... not tuned.

I can say yes - your claim is correct, they're not showing tuned results. But they're showing equally tuned results of before and after, with some rigor applied to the testing, demonstrating effective improvement under those conditions. That (keeping before/after conditions as similar as possible, including level of tuning) is what most companies fail at, which is probably why I overlooked your condition that they be tuned.

Sure, it would be interesting to see tuned dynos, but as Nameless has discovered, that's no guarantee of anything either... since no one seems to be able to quite reproduce their results.

C

[timmydatooth]

So I am browsing around at intakes and the injen sp1230 really caught my eye because it uses the dry filter which I like. Has great reviews too. Anyone have any experience with this intake? injen is a very reputable brand as well.

[Shinchu]

Injen started as a ricer brand. Some would say they still are. I would do some intake searches on here if i were you. And trust me, last year i was you. I just stumbled into my perrin by pure luck and convenience.

I get where you are comming from though. The choices these days are overwhelming.
Its the same reason i hate getting a drink at 711. Sooo many options!!!!

[timmydatooth]

Originally Posted by Shinchu

Injen started as a ricer brand. Some would say they still are. I would do some intake searches on here if i were you. And trust me, last year i was you. I just stumbled into my perrin by pure luck and convenience.

I get where you are comming from though. The choices these days are overwhelming.
Its the same reason i hate getting a drink at 711. Sooo many options!!!!

yeah ive been reading a lot of old post from the forum about intakes. A lot of recommendations for grimspeed. But I just dont like the whole oiled filter idea. For me it seems like the dry filters would be easier to maintain. When it comes to what kind of intake I want. I just want something that will give me the most gains and also is very simple to install. like without having to remove my bumper.

[scottman]

A drop-in and an inlet tube.

[nikitopo]

Before and after dyno is not so important. The ECU adapts to the new parameters and it is most important what is the output after some time.

Personally, I'll install next month a bigger throttle body. It is already on its way. I'll create a review afterwards.

[guybo]

You can find used intakes on Craigslist or OfferUp for half the price of new. There isn't much to gain, but there is a little. The sound and look are added bonuses of an intake IMHO. Some intakes move the MAF sensor closer to the TB which has some effect on throttle response too.

I've tried 3 intakes and I've gotten them all used. The K&N with silicone tube is in my closet, I resold the WeaponR and I have an Injen SP installed now. Find a used intake and try it out. If you don't like it, flip it.