New tires on one side?

[hypebrz]

I hopped a curb a few weeks ago, and the adjuster just gave me the estimate. It says they will replace with new stock tires and new wheels on the driver side since the wheels were dented in and the tires had chunks of rubber taken off. How will this affect the car having brand new tires with full tread on the left front and rear and worn tires that I drift on all the time on the right side front and rear?

Is there anyway they will replace all 4 out of concern for that being unsafe? I don't know much about the physics of tires so not sure how that affects safety anyway.

Anyone light shone on this topic for me will be greatly appreciated!

[MrDinkleman]

They won't pay for all four. But since the tires aren't directional just have the tire shop mount the two new tires in the rear and the two old tires at the front.

[hypebrz]

Originally Posted by MrDinkleman

They won't pay for all four. But since the tires aren't directional just have the tire shop mount the two new tires in the rear and the two old tires at the front.

Thanks for the quick reply. I read somewhere that the tires weren't ever supposed to be rotated from right to left or vise versa however. Did I just understand that wrong?

[MrDinkleman]

That was back in the day, probably more appropriate for bias-ply tires, not so much with today's radials. If you are still concerned, you can have one of the right side tires unmounted and remounted after being turned around so that the rotation will be the same direction on the left side.

[gramicci101]

Originally Posted by hypebrz

Thanks for the quick reply. I read somewhere that the tires weren't ever supposed to be rotated from right to left or vise versa however. Did I just understand that wrong?

Kind of. It depends on the tread of the tire. If it's a directional tread, then it needs to point a certain way. If it's correct on the right side, then it'll be backwards on the left side. You'd have to have them completely unmounted from the wheel and remounted to work on the left side. Our OEM tires aren't directional, so it's not a big deal.

[hypebrz]

Appreciate it guys, thanks!

[MrDinkleman]

Oh, I re-read my first post; you could/should always ask if they will replace all four tires. You can try to convince them by saying the front and rear tires aren't worn the same amount. It never hurts to ask; the worst that will happen is they will just say no.

[hypebrz]

Originally Posted by MrDinkleman

Oh, I re-read my first post; you could/should always ask if they will replace all four tires. You can try to convince them by saying the front and rear tires aren't worn the same amount. It never hurts to ask; the worst that will happen is they will just say no.

Also another question, they have my tires listed as:

"OE Replacement, Michelin Primacy 215/45R17 $165.00"

Could a shop put on different tires or do they have to follow what the estimate says? Because my local discount tire has Michelin PSS 245/45R17 for $160 and so it's a much better tire for cheaper.

[swarb]

Tell them to cut you a check and do whatever you want.

[MrDinkleman]

Originally Posted by swarb

Tell them to cut you a check and do whatever you want.

This is probably what is going to happen.

Originally Posted by hypebrz

Could a shop put on different tires or do they have to follow what the estimate says? Because my local discount tire has Michelin PSS 245/45R17 for $160 and so it's a much better tire for cheaper.

Having different types/makes/models of tires on your car is kind of "iffy" unless you know what you are doing and have an idea what effect having the different tires might have on handling. Maybe none, maybe dangerous. You might ask Michelin if they recommend mixing the two models...

[swarb]

Originally Posted by MrDinkleman

This is probably what is going to happen.


Having different types/makes/models of tires on your car is kind of "iffy" unless you know what you are doing and have an idea what effect having the different tires might have on handling. Maybe none, maybe dangerous. You might ask Michelin if they recommend mixing the two models...

I didn't suggest mixing and matching.

[PandaSPUR]

Originally Posted by swarb

I didn't suggest mixing and matching.

You didn't but it sounds like the OP is thinking bout it :|

If anything, buy all four PSS and then try to sell your two used tires. Assuming they're not horribly worn, guys who track their cars with stock tires may buy it?

[MrDinkleman]

Originally Posted by swarb

I didn't suggest mixing and matching.

Oops, sorry. I forgot to "multi-quote" when I wrote the two answers. Fixed it in post above. But PandaSpur is correct; looks like the OP is thinking of mixing, probably to save money (nothing wrong with that).

[hypebrz]

Originally Posted by PandaSPUR

You didn't but it sounds like the OP is thinking bout it :|

If anything, buy all four PSS and then try to sell your two used tires. Assuming they're not horribly worn, guys who track their cars with stock tires may buy it?

Well my question was if the insurance will allow the purchase of the PSS over the primacy since they're cheaper and better. If this was the case, I would buy the other 2 myself lol, no plans to mix and match