Thanks for all the concern guys but I'll somehow get this squared away. I had the technicians log a sample of the fuel the first time they called me, so I'll have that to show the station along with my bill.
@
Tcoat I was able to get back that night because I filled up with just less than a quarter of a tank left and then drove home straight after, so the water didn't have time to settle. Draining the system is simple enough but the technician mentioned how they'd have to get someone to come pick up the bad fuel and dispose of it and that would the most expensive thing. They're also replacing the fuel pump which in this scenario is not under warranty. Once I see the fuel sample I'll let you know if the technician exaggerated or not.
The gas station I went to has been my regular for years, and it's one of the busiest ones I've seen in the area. A lot of trucks stop there in the early hours of the day and there are times where people are literally queued up to get a pump. I was very shocked when I found out about the fuel because I had always thought of this station as reliable.
Once I have the bill and fuel sample, my mission will be to get them to admit to other customer complaints and then I'll have 'em.