FIXED. kinda.
After I reflashed the Procede, twice, with Sojhinn's rev 2 map and re-calibrated the throttle which seemed to fix the issue. The first time I flashed it there was some weird stuttering going on so I had to double flash. After driving around for awhile I realized that my batteries DO have some issues as a second gear pull would drop my voltage down to the 17.Xs and shut off the ESC temporarily. I'm not sure if this is the root cause of the failure or if the calibration was thrown off somehow but either way it seems mostly fixed now.
I only had my ESC taken off completely for a day but it reminded me just how slow our cars without FI are <_<. It feels like there is literally no pull below 5000rpm.
I would like to thank everyone for the suggestions and Sojhinn for the amazing Procede map (I used rev2). The map seems to be much smoother than standard.