| akiranakayama |
01-29-2016 05:07 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anthony
(Post 2527561)
I like the FA20 and would never swap to another 4 cylinder.
But... if you've got a stock FA20 in your car, but a fully built 4 banger sitting around, I can see it being worth it. My main concern with engine swaps is always balance and center of gravity. It's hard to beat the FA20.
|
Vorshlag Motorsports, who are doing an LSx swap in their FR-S, looked at the arrangment of the FA20 in the chassis and ascertained that, while low in CoG, it is heavy and not great for F:R weight distribution. The bell housing of the transmission is long, necessitating a long shift linkage, and more than 1/2 of the engine mass is in front of the front axle centerline. The FA20 is also the heaviest four cylinder aluminum engine they've ever weighed (presumably of similar displacement).
Skip to the "What's So Wrong With The Subaru FA20 Boxer Engine?": http://www.vorshlag.com/forums/showthread.php?t=8275
I personally wouldn't ever swap a V8 into this car, I think the FA20 is perfectly suited for this application. Especially since I don't ever really plan to mod the engine for power. For reliability? Yes. I think if anything, it seemed like maybe the engineers could have improved the weight distribution by moving the engine rearward and used a shorter bell housing, but perhaps the bean counters intervened. I could see an argument for change in that area, but not swapping the engine entirely.
BUT. Some people want MOAR POWER. And that's totally legit.
It's probably impossible to get a similarly low CoG with another engine (except maybe with another horizontally opposed powerplant). But if you're willing to look past that, I don't see why an SRT mill or similar wouldn't be eye-wateringly fun in this chassis.
I'm personally waiting for someone to swap in a frankenstein Honda K24 into a Twin. K24 block, K20 head, TVS1320 positive displacement blower with A/W chargecooling, figure out a way to keep the gears from eating themselves and I'm sure you'd have a reliable track-ready weapon on your hands. Even though the CoG would be higher, you'd likely lose some weight in the process and gain a BUNCH of power and torque. Hell, even if you decided on an all-motor build, you'd get much more torque with the extra displacement not to mention a much more reliable motor with better fuel economy without all the direct injection complication. Of course, you'd probably have a nightmare of a wiring job awaiting you to integrate the gauges and various sub-systems.
|