[Giccin]

Deciding factor for me... would be.. "What more can I get for my amount of money?" And... if one of them will become a hatch. The one with the hatch will be the deciding factor for me if it were up to the two. Cost omitted.

I don't like Scion's protruding rear lights and I don't like that rear break light (not sure if removable yet).
I like the 86 emblem on the wheel and ontop of the fender.

I don't like Subaru's Upper fender design (looks like a fake vent kinda)
I like subaru's rear and simple yet slightly aggressive look in the front.

Also the.... be called a fake subaru because it isn't AWD (sorry subie fan boys) or a Scion ricing d-bag (No offense to the great scion owners at all. The negatives of scion out-weighs the good drivers)