Okay then the G37 and the 370Z.
G37 = high 13s - $38k - 4 seats
370Z = low 13s - $32k - 2 seats
GC 3.8 = mid 13s - $27k - 4 seats (no telling what the 2013 model will offer)
Nothing about those numbers makes me feel like the GC is blown away by either the G37 or 370Z. The 370Z is a little faster (as compared to the 2012 GC), but it's $5k more and doesn't have rear seats.
I highly admire Hyundai for pushing the GC like they have. They are stepping it up a notch, and I think that rocks. They are going after what many people want, at a good price. Things like "handling characteristics" and looks are up to the individual buyer. But if it's cheaper, it's cheaper, if it's faster, it's faster.
It is what it is
Instead of us all waiting and looking towards Toyota to "bring back
a sports car" - look at what Hyundai is doing, they're creating a legacy of their own and it's happening right in front of us.
Even if I tried, I could not dislike the GC. I just can't. It offers too much bang for the buck, and the new one looks like it's going to be even better.
NOT putting the FR-S out, we just don't know enough about it yet - if it's a good deal, it's a good deal - To me, the GC is a great deal.