Just to throw in my 2 cents .. of really no experience besides researching about speakers and stuff over night ..
Of the 2 you suggested I THINK this would be the better speaker.
https://www.crutchfield.com/p_108R40...fx.html?tp=105
I say this because it has better sensitivity (92 vs 88), lower impedance 3 vs 3.5 (stock is 2 in the doors, thus 3 will be louder than 3.5 but quieter than the stocks 2), wider frequency range 75-21k vs 150-10k Hz, and closer to stock (33 watts) RMS/peak watts 35/105 vs 75/300.
-----
This is what I would like to test out personally:
Dayton Audio DSN25F-4 1" [
https://www.parts-express.com/dayton...#lblProductQ&A ]
Dayton Audio ND90-4 3-1/2" [
https://www.parts-express.com/dayton...4-ohm--290-208 ]
Infinity Primus PR6512IS [
https://www.amazon.com/Infinity-PR65.../dp/B073QXD1XF ] - or - Infinity Reference 6522EX [
https://www.amazon.com/Infinity-REF-.../dp/B01FUZV7ZG ] ← 2.7 ohms vs 3 ohms .. don't know how much louder the 2.7 would be.
Kenwood KSC-SW11 [
https://www.amazon.com/Kenwood-KSC-S.../dp/B00BO8O9XQ ]