[AnotherSlowAE86]

I've bought and sold many cars in my time. Here's the best advice I can give you is to go see both cars in person. Some times seeing them in person will cast them in a light than photos couldn't. You may also find the paint on one is in better shape than the other.

Beyond that, I've find having a neutral paint color is more useful when choosing wheel colors. It allows for a greater number of colors and styles to match without clashing.