A little update guys...I ended up going with a body shop rather than the dealership, from your advice.
I just got my car back this morning and I love the results. I had the bumper and fender plus the side light replaced and you couldn’t even tell anything was done!
You guys were right the body shop had great service, waxed the whole car and cleaned it up. And they gave me a free rental as well!
Plus...the body shop didn’t drill holes into the bumper, which I always hated. Now I can use a plate relocator!
So thanks for all the suggestions guys, really appreciate it!