I was in this same dilemma, I wanted to plastidip my wheels and came across autodip and didn't know which one to use. My cousin had his truck wheels dipped and it was an easy application but I did notice that they were rubbery/sticky to the touch. I did some research on plastidip and came across autodip and the one thing I liked about it was that it had a non rubbery/sticky feel to it. I wash my car a lot and wanted something that was smooth and could be easily wiped down. I went with matte black autodip and happy with how it turned out. Like everybody else is saying pre is key, I read up on a lot of forum post and videos on how to do it (this was the my first time ever spraying wheels so its not 100%).
Some pics of how it turned out...
You can see in the top right corner were I had to do a touch up...
