[soulreapersteve]

So whats your budget? This looks to be a private sale, yes? If so, can you ask if the owner of the higher mileage one provide records of maintenance work done? Can you also wrench if need be? Nothing wrong with going to a shop, there may be more stuff needed to be done on the higher mileage one... Too hard to tell from this post alone.

Also, are you going to keep this car long term or get something else in the near future? If you are going to keep the car for 5+ years, I'd say go for lower mile one.

I wanted to be first owner and planning on keeping it long term, so I bought brand new at ~50 on the clock.