I imagine these three come up often in comparisons. However, they are very different cars. As most have suggested, try to drive them back to back and choose which one is more fun to you. As much as I wanted to go with a used Cayman S, I need a back seat in a pinch.
The BRZ makes a great daily driver in stock form. You'll also see good gas mileage. Maintenance is low and prices for parts are cheap. Heck, you can get an entire engine/mission from a low mile wrecker for cheaper than you may pay to get repairs done on the Porsche.
|