I traded my less than 2 year old 2013 Golf R for my BRZ, and I'm glad I did. I looked at the BRZ when it was first released, but did not think I could live with 2 doors and 2 seats. As a VW Audi fan, it was not difficult to buy the R. There were a lot of things I liked about the R. Nice interior fit/finish. Comfortable and quiet. Utility of a 4 door hatch. Quick and sure footed handling (with a bit of understeer). Rising Blue color.
But, I don't miss it at all.
The BRZ is so much more enjoyable to drive. I feel connected to the suspension, steering and the chassis. It just feels good.