|
If you want to keep the steering and turn-in feel, I'd probably go with the 18x8+35 and a 225/40 tire all around. You have to remember that your BMW was a bigger, heavier car, and its suspension was designed from the factory to run staggered fitment.
Keep in mind also that your ride will be a little rougher on 18's than it will on 17's, purely because there's less tire sidewall to absorb impact. If you decided to go 17x8, I would get a 225/45 tire. Or a 17x7 with a 215/45, OEM sizing. Just because the OEM tire sucks doesn't mean that the size isn't enough for these cars. An MPSS or Continental DW in 215/45 will be a big improvement over OEM.
|