Funny story I had to share with fellow FT86ers..
I went to STS Tire and Battery to see if they would price match or beat Tire Rack for ordering tires.
Me: "I want a quote on some tires, Hankook V12 255/35/18 rear and 225/40/18 front"
STS: "What kind of car?"
Me: "13 Subaru BRZ...."
STS: "Your car isn't showing a staggered setup."
Me: "I know.. I have aftermarket rims it will be fine"
STS: "We won't be able to put staggered tires on your car, it doesn't come like that"
Me: "I know, hence why I bought new rims. They are wider in the rear to accommodate it.."
STS: "I don't think that will work, your car can only fit 215 tires."
I left.
I don't know if the guy was new or what.. but wow.