The truth is in the asterisks.
Scion FR-S/Subaru BRZ The chassis that was such a revelation in 2013 is still squirming under these Japanese twins, but its brilliance so blinded us that it took a year to notice that almost every other aspect is only average or worse. Still, keep either one in the garage for track days and canyon-road blasts.
** We're not getting paid enough to say anything good about this car anymore.