Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB

Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/index.php)
-   Tracking / Autocross / HPDE / Drifting (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=39)
-   -   225/45/17 vs 245/40/17 Same Compound and Wheel, which is faster (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=152019)

nissanfanatic 01-16-2023 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RT-BRZ (Post 3564491)
All very interesting data. The only thing that's tough to get past is that the 225 tire at the same aspect ratio is taller than the 215 tire. While the difference is pretty small, there is a difference there and it does make the results suspect. I'm not saying I doubt them but there is enough variability to make more questions.

The wet results are not surprising. Water creates drag and a wider tire is going to have more of it.

In a straight line the narrower tire is going to be faster because of less drag. The wider tire has the opportunity to make up for this in turns where the lateral grip is greater. In the wet the water acts as a lubricant and therefore reduces lateral grip for everyone which effectively nullifies the advantage.

It would be kind of neat to see a track map of speeds/times comparing these tires against each other.

Agree. I kind of wish they had posted the usual charts like they do for other tests. But, I also try not to be a choosing beggar lol because it's nice to finally have this tested _and_ on our platform nonetheless.

cmiovino 01-20-2023 11:54 AM

Speaking in terms of autocross only, it's common that everyone is putting as wide of a tire on as possible. All our second gen guys (and there's a lot of them) are running 245's and even 255's on a 7.5". They do extended studs, spacers, and max offset per the rules to achieve this. Note that I'm just talking about autocross, but our courses are very much like smaller tracks similar to the TireRack testing facility.

I personally run 225/45/17 because it's what you can get away with without going the spacer/stud route... and because having Brembos limits your wheel choices heavily. Interesting to see what 225 on the proper wheel generally is even with 245's on the same width... at least per TR's testing.

ZDan 01-20-2023 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RT-BRZ (Post 3564491)
All very interesting data. The only thing that's tough to get past is that the 225 tire at the same aspect ratio is taller than the 215 tire.

What would have been GREAT would be if they also tested 235/45-17 (and maybe 235/40-17 as well).

The 225 results appear to overachieve relative to 215 and 245 rather than just interpolating between them. Could be due to "better" gearing for this particular course? Seeing results for 235/45 and 235/40 could help clear that issue up.

MacSpeed 01-20-2023 02:03 PM

The TR test are better than nothing but still need to be taken with a grain of salt.

They do not adjust tire pressures for one. They run what the door says for psi. once that is changed and FSB is added to the mix like street class autox plus bump stop tuning and shocks, these results get thrown on their head.

Don't get me wrong, this is all cool data but I would be careful pulling hard absolutes from it.

jflogerzi 01-22-2023 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MacSpeed (Post 3565077)
The TR test are better than nothing but still need to be taken with a grain of salt.



They do not adjust tire pressures for one. They run what the door says for psi. once that is changed and FSB is added to the mix like street class autox plus bump stop tuning and shocks, these results get thrown on their head.



Don't get me wrong, this is all cool data but I would be careful pulling hard absolutes from it.

I don't think anyone is putting it as be it 100% Truth. And I agree tire pressure is going to have more impact.

Sent from my Pixel 6 using Tapatalk

MX-5RACER 02-21-2023 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cmiovino (Post 3565053)
Speaking in terms of autocross only, it's common that everyone is putting as wide of a tire on as possible. All our second gen guys (and there's a lot of them) are running 245's and even 255's on a 7.5".

Everything goes out the window when speaking in terms of autocross. I can still remember the days of people putting 275 Hoosiers on 6" wide rims on DS Type R Integras back in the day.

As with anything else, test as much as you can. Keep in mind that for some of us, $/run or lap weighs heavily on the tire and width choice.

A friend of mine once said that the RA-1's suck compared to a Hoosier, but they suck for a LONG time.

GrandSport 03-01-2023 10:15 AM

edit: doh, wrong thread!

Scargod 04-06-2023 11:53 AM

255's, and when?
 
What I'm curious about, and don't see much about, is what horsepower does to our tire selection. I can only assume that people are stock unless they say otherwise.
Then you start gutting, lowering, adding aero. All that is not clear unless stated, which it seldom is, or perhaps you go digging for the poster's info.

I've seen people talk about running 255's on road courses. I think some (most?) have turbo's.

I get 230 HP from my 2022 BRZ. I've no rear interior, but I have a wing and splitter. I'd guess I'm under 2,800 with light 17" wheels, rotors, coilovers, lighter exhaust.
I'm very happy with the performance of my 245 F1 Supercar's. Good lap times.
So, could there be an advantage for me on tighter, shorter courses with 255's? If it's only 50-75°F will there be an issue getting them up to temp?
Goodyear doesn't make an F1 Supercar tire in 255 though there are tires like Falken's and Kumho's, but is their lesser traction performance outweighed by their larger surface area? I'm not going to go to Hoosiers or similar that cost a lot for the laps.

RedReplicant 04-09-2023 04:17 PM

I have never had issues getting a 245 on a 10 or 255 on a 9, 9.5, or 10 to temp even in a car that weighed 2400lb with me in it and made 220whp (and I still don't with my current car at 2850 min / 205 avg whp). I'm more worried about the drop-off from heat after 1-3 laps depending on tire.

Assuming you're talking SC3R there isn't much faster other than going Hoosier. GRM did tests a while ago with a more narrow A052 vs another couple wider super 200tw tires, if you dig around though.

timurrrr 01-10-2024 03:24 PM

I love data.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_Lq8HtHNWY

RedReplicant 01-10-2024 03:40 PM

Andy also wrote another semi related article a few days ago too

https://grassrootsmotorsports.com/ar...ize-comparison

GrandSport 01-11-2024 10:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scargod (Post 3575820)
What I'm curious about, and don't see much about, is what horsepower does to our tire selection. I can only assume that people are stock unless they say otherwise.
Then you start gutting, lowering, adding aero. All that is not clear unless stated, which it seldom is, or perhaps you go digging for the poster's info.

I've seen people talk about running 255's on road courses. I think some (most?) have turbo's.

I get 230 HP from my 2022 BRZ. I've no rear interior, but I have a wing and splitter. I'd guess I'm under 2,800 with light 17" wheels, rotors, coilovers, lighter exhaust.
I'm very happy with the performance of my 245 F1 Supercar's. Good lap times.
So, could there be an advantage for me on tighter, shorter courses with 255's? If it's only 50-75°F will there be an issue getting them up to temp?
Goodyear doesn't make an F1 Supercar tire in 255 though there are tires like Falken's and Kumho's, but is their lesser traction performance outweighed by their larger surface area? I'm not going to go to Hoosiers or similar that cost a lot for the laps.

I think that a variable not given adequate consideration is alignment.
If you can't get enough negative camber to get the tire flat, it really doesn't mattter how much tire is not touching the ground (or doesn't have significant load).

So yeah, when you're only riding on the outside inch of tire around turns because these tires are so grippy these days, regardless of the tire width, the tire that is 10% lighter will be faster.

ZDan 01-11-2024 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GrandSport (Post 3599859)
If you can't get enough negative camber to get the tire flat, it really doesn't mattter how much tire is not touching the ground (or doesn't have significant load).

So yeah, when you're only riding on the outside inch of tire around turns because these tires are so grippy these days, regardless of the tire width, the tire that is 10% lighter will be faster.

IMO opposite should be more generally true. If you don't have enough camber, a wider tire should roll over onto the sidewall less.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.


Garage vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.