| Turbowned |
08-16-2012 09:25 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr 286
(Post 384109)
It has to be something with the dynamics? Really? So I guess the testing programs from two world-class auto manufacturers wasn't able to detect this problem that you can clearly see from a few second hand accident reports on the Internet.
Have you driven an FR-S or BRZ? From what empirical evidence do you base this claim?
|
Yes, I have driven them and yes, it is possible for them to overlook these things. Hence why I made an example of the 1991-1992 MR2's as being prone to snap oversteer and causing a lot of accidents. The 1993-1995 model year MR2's were changed to a staggered tire setup as a result. They also eliminated the rear trunk in the MR2 Spyder because a full trunk in the earlier cars could upset the balance enough to cause snap oversteer issues. If you listen to what some of the pro drivers say, here's your empirical data:
Randy Pobst: "I like the Subaru better, primarily because it's less loose on entry. In the Scion, you feel the back move almost before the front. In the Subaru, it's more one piece. And I can be more aggressive entering turns with the Subaru. It's a decreasing maneuver -- I'm entering on the brakes and cornering -- and because the Subaru isn't as tail-happy, I can use more brakes entering the corner and carry more speed in. It's the same thing coming off the corner. The Subaru doesn't oversteer as easily, so I can get to the power sooner."
And the staff of Motor Trend said similar:
Lago: "The BRZ seems a bit slower to transition from understeer to oversteer than the FR-S. It stays neutral longer, where the FR-S switches quickly back and forth. I was able to hold the BRZ right in that space between the two extremes longer, and I like that extra stability."
Mortara: "Like other Subarus, the BRZ rolls, something that I actually like. This is what gives the BRZ an edge over the FR-S. The roll makes the car less edgy, less prone to kick the rear out, unless you really want it to."
Jurnecka: "On the track and skidpad, the BRZ just feels a little more dialed-in than the FR-S. There's a little more grip and a little more control -- all very, very small stuff, but it's noticeable."
Read more: http://m.motortrend.com/roadtests/co...#ixzz23l5aPjbI
|