Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB

Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/index.php)
-   Tracking / Autocross / HPDE / Drifting (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=39)
-   -   Brake fade is getting out of hand (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=146759)

Jstyle 09-03-2021 08:11 AM

Brake fade is getting out of hand
 
Over the last year I’ve definitely learned I could control brake fade… to a certain extent by not stabbing the brakes (which is just a good idea period and a part of learning), better cool down laps… etc… etc… etc…

Well at Summit Point Main yesterday, it didn’t matter how much I babied the brakes I had nothing by the end of the day. I kept having to back my brake points further and further and further back. On top of that my rotors are pretty warped at this point as well… The pulsing going into turn 1 was intense by the end of the day :bonk:

So since I have to buy and oil cooler now I’m just not in a place where I can buy that AND a BBK at the moment. Will buying just a nice set of stock sized rotors that are drilled and/or slotted help? Any recommendations on which rotors to get? Also I still have the stock brake lines which I haven’t changed yet because the car has just a little over 2k miles so I haven’t even crossed that bridge yet, could that be causing some of it?

I already have XP10’s in the front and XP8’s in the back.

soundman98 09-03-2021 09:06 AM

what fluid are you running?

Jstyle 09-03-2021 09:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by soundman98 (Post 3462682)
what fluid are you running?

Motul660

NoHaveMSG 09-03-2021 09:49 AM

Brake fade is getting out of hand
 
The pulsing is not warped rotors. It is the pads depositing material on them in uneven smears. Carbotech pads suck. I had the same issue with XP10s. Do you you have brake ducting ?

Vesartis 09-03-2021 09:51 AM

My obvious guess is that it sounds like your fluid needs to be bled or changed if the pedal is getting soft. Pulsing or "warping" usually is a pad deposit problem rather than the rotor itself, especially if it goes away on the street. The way to manage that would be to get a more heat resistant pad. Yours might be fine, but there might be more exotic options. (CSG Spec, etc.) As far as rotors, I've heard that financially it makes more sense to stick with blanks and replace more frequently, because the cooling benefit from fancy rotors alone isn't much.

A cheap stopgap would be a makeshift air deflector on the lower control arm that would divert air to the front brakes. There's no fully premade solution, but it's a concept used in other cars. I use a Porsche GT3 part that I cut up a bit and zip tied, and it extended my hot laps maybe 15-20%.

Are you turning off traction control? Doing the pedal dance when comfortable? With traction/stability on, the system will be overusing the brakes very quickly. Even with it "off", the rear brakes are being used a lot, and can overheat if you are driving aggressively.

Jstyle 09-03-2021 10:13 AM

No I don’t have ducting at all. Maybe that’s a good next step. Now that you mention it I don’t have any shake or pulsing on the street.

ZDan 09-03-2021 10:15 AM

Above questions all good ^^^ How often do you bleed, any nannies on, track mode, 3-second hold on TC button? etc.
For me, 3-second hold worked fine at 11/10ths and beyond. But "Track Mode" is too intrusive...

IMO should go with square pads, it's possible that with XP10/XP8 the rears aren't helping out enough. Never understood why so many insist on "staggered" pads, it just gives too much front bias in the only cases I'm familiar with (240Z, FD, S2000, BRZ)

Also worth noting I've *never* had any issues just running off-the-shelf name-brand DOT4 or DOT5.1 from AutoZone/PepBoys/etc. even in the 550hp FD. In my limited experience with them, "race" brake fluids don't seem to last nearly as long before pedal starts to feel soft. I can get 6+ track days out of "normal" brake fluid.

blsfrs 09-03-2021 11:04 AM

I ran Summit Point last fall. I have a n/a FRS with stock suspension and brakes. I have xp8, blank Ebay rotors on all 4 corners, and used Motul 600. I do have braided "soft" lines. I've run VIR with the same set up and have no problems. I try not to use my brakes on the cool down and I don't set my ebrake when parked in the paddock. Maybe the staggered set up is causing the problem.

rice_classic 09-03-2021 01:47 PM

Assuming no brake ducts.

Street pads + lack of ducts is a pretty inevitable outcome. You'll have to step up your hardware.

Buy proper race pads and a set of brake ducts. If you can't do ducts yet, start with proper pads. Before the event grab your 14mm wrench and swap in your track only pads (they'll be fine on the drive to the track) and you'll enjoy your day much more.

Lots of good options here too: Raybestos ST series, CSG, GLOC, Cobalt XR1 etc.

NoHaveMSG 09-03-2021 02:07 PM

Brake fade is getting out of hand
 
This is XP10 on BBK. Same compound F&R. You can see the smears all over the friction rings.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...c4082ffe5d.jpg

blsfrs 09-03-2021 02:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vesartis (Post 3462695)
My obvious guess is that it sounds like your fluid needs to be bled or changed if the pedal is getting soft. Pulsing or "warping" usually is a pad deposit problem rather than the rotor itself, especially if it goes away on the street. The way to manage that would be to get a more heat resistant pad. Yours might be fine, but there might be more exotic options. (CSG Spec, etc.) As far as rotors, I've heard that financially it makes more sense to stick with blanks and replace more frequently, because the cooling benefit from fancy rotors alone isn't much.

A cheap stopgap would be a makeshift air deflector on the lower control arm that would divert air to the front brakes. There's no fully premade solution, but it's a concept used in other cars. I use a Porsche GT3 part that I cut up a bit and zip tied, and it extended my hot laps maybe 15-20%.

Are you turning off traction control? Doing the pedal dance when comfortable? With traction/stability on, the system will be overusing the brakes very quickly. Even with it "off", the rear brakes are being used a lot, and can overheat if you are driving aggressively.


Do you have pictures of your GT3 deflectors? I just got a set and have had to trim the crap off the front side to clear my wheels. I haven't been able work out a ziptie configuration to get them to stay in place. Did you leave your backing plates intact?

Jstyle 09-03-2021 03:19 PM

So I just pulled off the wheels to check the pads and they are absolutely smoked. Like almost nothing left. The brakes got so hot it melted the rubber bleed valve cover to the brake. I think maybe it’s because there was almost no pad left which had nowhere to dissipate heat… Maybe. My back XP8’s are still almost full of life, my 10’s are just shot. I guess time for a new pad. I’ll check into ducting as well.

Vesartis 09-03-2021 03:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blsfrs (Post 3462787)
Do you have pictures of your GT3 deflectors? I just got a set and have had to trim the crap off the front side to clear my wheels. I haven't been able work out a ziptie configuration to get them to stay in place. Did you leave your backing plates intact?

Pics

They definitely aren't sturdy. I bent the little triangle of the dust shield but I think ideally you want to take them off. I don't run them since switching to CSG pads, since they ended up makin the braking feel inconsistent.

CSG Mike 09-03-2021 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jstyle (Post 3462672)
Over the last year I’ve definitely learned I could control brake fade… to a certain extent by not stabbing the brakes (which is just a good idea period and a part of learning), better cool down laps… etc… etc… etc…

Well at Summit Point Main yesterday, it didn’t matter how much I babied the brakes I had nothing by the end of the day. I kept having to back my brake points further and further and further back. On top of that my rotors are pretty warped at this point as well… The pulsing going into turn 1 was intense by the end of the day :bonk:

So since I have to buy and oil cooler now I’m just not in a place where I can buy that AND a BBK at the moment. Will buying just a nice set of stock sized rotors that are drilled and/or slotted help? Any recommendations on which rotors to get? Also I still have the stock brake lines which I haven’t changed yet because the car has just a little over 2k miles so I haven’t even crossed that bridge yet, could that be causing some of it?

I already have XP10’s in the front and XP8’s in the back.

That's a very entry level, beginner setup, which you're clearly FAR beyond, if you've already realized and learned how to modulate FADE, let alone just braking.

Try the CSG C2 front and rear. Yes, non-staggered.

If you want to get even more life and capacity, go CE2 front C2 rear.

CSG Mike 09-03-2021 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vesartis (Post 3462809)
Pics

They definitely aren't sturdy. I bent the little triangle of the dust shield but I think ideally you want to take them off. I don't run them since switching to CSG pads, since they ended up makin the braking feel inconsistent.

Ducting is always a last resort. It introduces thermal stress from the temperature swings that you ideally want to avoid.


Real world example: Porsche RS-R GT-LM cover up the brake duct as much as possible and use the absolute bare minimum. Look at photos from different track to see different levels of open-ness on the duct. Sebring? Big opening. Long Beach? Medium opening. Watkins? Small opening.

ZDan 09-03-2021 05:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CSG Mike (Post 3462828)
Try the CSG C2 front and rear. Yes, non-staggered.

I'm running front rear (without ABS), like 'em a lot...
This is after being disappointed with XP10, Winmax W5, PMu CR, etc.
Great but not too grabby bite, consistent performance over wide temperatures, not too too loud, dust is not bad, they're fairly durable, and pretty streetable as well.

Jstyle 09-03-2021 08:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CSG Mike (Post 3462828)
That's a very entry level, beginner setup, which you're clearly FAR beyond, if you've already realized and learned how to modulate FADE, let alone just braking.

Try the CSG C2 front and rear. Yes, non-staggered.

If you want to get even more life and capacity, go CE2 front C2 rear.

How long should pads be lasting me? I have been eyeing those for a while.

CSG Mike 09-03-2021 09:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jstyle (Post 3462885)
How long should pads be lasting me? I have been eyeing those for a while.

Life varies by driver, car prep, track, conditions, etc., but typically if you're needing to replace pads every 5 track days or less, you can probably use an upgrade.

You can also look at it as 8 hours of track time or less, you can probably use an upgrade.


With brakes, too much is often safe, but not enough results in both dangerous situations as well as having expensive paperweights.

soundman98 09-03-2021 09:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CSG Mike (Post 3462831)
Ducting is always a last resort. It introduces thermal stress from the temperature swings that you ideally want to avoid.


Real world example: Porsche RS-R GT-LM cover up the brake duct as much as possible and use the absolute bare minimum. Look at photos from different track to see different levels of open-ness on the duct. Sebring? Big opening. Long Beach? Medium opening. Watkins? Small opening.

interesting, hadn't considered the thermal stress angle.

has anyone done testing to putting the ducting behind the radiator, which would pre-warm some of the air but still maintain a positive air flow?

CSG Mike 09-03-2021 10:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by soundman98 (Post 3462892)
interesting, hadn't considered the thermal stress angle.

has anyone done testing to putting the ducting behind the radiator, which would pre-warm some of the air but still maintain a positive air flow?

Let's say your radiator has 100% efficiency (it doesn't), and warms the air to 180F. That's still a huge difference from a 800F rotor.

50F, 100F, or 180F, is still all a huge difference to a 800F rotor.

You're better off using a smaller amount of air (it'll all mix anyways), rather than "warmer" air.

Icecreamtruk 09-03-2021 10:34 PM

As a drop of extra info. I removed my ducts when I went to a BBK setup. My discs were cracking by the time I got to replace my pads on OEM size, I didnt want to risk the more expensive 2 piece rotors crack as fast, considering pads would last much more than before. So far, I change rotors with pads as a precaution, but they could still go on. (lastting about 2-3 times as much as before the BBK).

Nickel 09-21-2021 01:49 PM

Damn, this is surprising. I just put on new XP8's F&R with new blank rotors for the street and the stopping power is almost as comparable to my 2016 Mustang GTPP with 6 piston brembos and 15" rotors, but they don't bite anywhere near as hard. Still, I've put them through their paces on the street, but I plan to track the car next year and was hoping they would hold up. I guess we'll see.

Jstyle 09-21-2021 02:07 PM

1 Attachment(s)
So after going with PMU Club racers on the front I’m sold on their ability to not fade. I was really pushing them hard all day long for a 2 day in the 90’s by the second day and they kept asking for more.

The longevity is a bit in question because I’m not sure they’re going to last long. This is after just a 2 day.

CSG Mike 09-21-2021 11:54 PM

You've already faded them, just not catastrophically.

You MIGHT get 3 more days out of them, but likely will be having issues on the 4th an 5th day.

blsfrs 09-22-2021 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jstyle (Post 3467567)
So after going with PMU Club racers on the front I’m sold on their ability to not fade. I was really pushing them hard all day long for a 2 day in the 90’s by the second day and they kept asking for more.

The longevity is a bit in question because I’m not sure they’re going to last long. This is after just a 2 day.

What tires are you running? Any suspension mods? N/A engine?

Jstyle 09-22-2021 02:11 PM

245/40/17 Falken 660's
Fortune 500
Just headers and a tune as far as engine goes

NoHaveMSG 09-22-2021 02:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jstyle (Post 3467567)
So after going with PMU Club racers on the front I’m sold on their ability to not fade. I was really pushing them hard all day long for a 2 day in the 90’s by the second day and they kept asking for more.

The longevity is a bit in question because I’m not sure they’re going to last long. This is after just a 2 day.

PMU pads seem to crumble like that. There is a localish guy to me with a stock performance package car with SX2's. He had the same issue with the Club Racer pads.

blsfrs 09-22-2021 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jstyle (Post 3467857)
245/40/17 Falken 660's
Fortune 500
Just headers and a tune as far as engine goes

How do you like the Fortune 500's. I've been eyeballing the 510 as an upgrade from stock.

Jstyle 09-23-2021 08:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blsfrs (Post 3468015)
How do you like the Fortune 500's. I've been eyeballing the 510 as an upgrade from stock.

I only have 3 days on them so far but I love them. Definitely a huge upgrade from stock.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:59 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.


Garage vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.