| Jordanwolf |
01-03-2021 04:16 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kodename47
(Post 3397339)
Yes and I think if you're in the market you would possibly cross-shop the 2. The problem, as you say, is that there are no other cars in either B/C segment that are remotely similar - remember that in Europe we no longer get any fun Subaru models (BRZ exited not long after the WRX/STi) and there are no others out there. CTR and Mini GP are both more lap time setters than the Yaris. Doesn't necessarily make them better on the road, but for around £35k you're really looking at the best drivers hot hatches or the 2nd tier "premium" hot hatches. I'm not sure a comparison needs to be all of the same, if I were in the market for a hatch with that type of cash, comparing a few different ones would be ideal for helping me choose - what's a better DD, track day toy, weekend B-road weapon etc.
|
I completely forgot the STi was taken out of that market.. this is the car I think would best compare that actually exists.
I understand the road testing and comparisons with the CTR, it's just the performance testing that makes no sense. If like you say, you're shopping for a car that can best do all of these things (DD, backroad, track), the AWD car is usually going to come out on top if you have bad enough weather, especially during winter.
The primary goal here seems to be fun, and the amount of hype behind the Yaris supports it greatly in the eastern world. Doing a track test where the CTR then beats it will skew peoples perception of what the car was meant for. Everyone likes to have this idea that one car can do everything, but it just isn't the reality.
Truly the Yaris stands on it's own with no competitors, I think this helps it's popularity greatly. People with access to both these cars should honestly just buy the Yaris, unless someone is hellbent on having a track weapon, I think the Yaris would be more than adequate.
I guess what I'm trying to say is, one is an everyday touring car, the other is an everyday rally car. It's kind of similar to CTR vs Golf R, which is another joke... but CTR vs Golf TCR, that's much more interesting.
|