A calmer "lol" smiley
 

I feel that the two "lol" smiley options (:bellyroll: and :lol:) are too extreme in terms of the amount of hilarity they convey. I'd like to request a milder "lol" smiley be added to the list. I can provide samples if necessary. Thanks for your time. :lol:

Not a bad idea. Maybe this one :lol: but just the beginning part when the smiley is facing forward.

Maybe the solution isn't less enthusiastic smileys, maybe it is funnier posts.

:clap: :bow: :happy0180:

If it's not that funny, use unamused.
http://allch-chcar.com/saved/blankface.gif
http://allch-chcar.com/saved/unamusedrun.gif

I tend to use the big grin :D if it's not funny enough for bellyroll or lol.

We need a head to brick wall emoticon for all the fail/idiot threads/posts

"lol" it's a man drowning

:lol:

Yeah I was thinking the same thing. That front-facing laugh part on loop would be good.