Swap your Scion key emblem for a Toyota
 

Found this on eBay. Looks like they have 2.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/TOYOTA-GENUI...ht_1519wt_1163


I've already done this with a rental car Corolla swap. Mine's on the left :)
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-C...KA/s821/12+-+2

Funny, I was just playing with my key a bit earlier thinking about this. I have the JDM emblems, wheel caps, and key cover on the way.

Do you just pry it apart with a thin flathead and then re-assemble? Or is there some really tiny screw(s)?

That is going to REALLY confuse the rental guys...

Super easy, just pop it off with a small flathead, and replace with Toyota.

LOL. I just did them a favor and pulled off the Scion emblem. Didn't want any questions asked when I handed them back a key to a Corolla with a Scion emblem on it.

Hah, they're probably wondering.. "Why would someone want the Toyota key cover over the Scion one...?"

LoL, I was hoping to see the update of their reaction when you gave them that key! :)