Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB

Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/index.php)
-   Engine, Exhaust, Transmission (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Crack in My ofh (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=118238)

FISHBURGLAR 05-05-2017 12:03 AM

Jdl uel was ordered today with ceramic coating. Lifetime warranty and good torque for daily driving, and good price. Already have adjusted ots tune 93 for these.once they come in I will install asap, and redo the exhaust. Will make custom exhaust, and add a flex pipe towards the middle where catback should meet front pipe. As A safety measure. New grimspeed gaskets, and vibrant gaskets for exhaust.
Going for simple, not to loud, and cut weight.

Thank you all for staying attentive.

FISHBURGLAR 05-05-2017 12:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by steve99 (Post 2904593)
Alternative to thermal coating header is to adjust radiator fan activation temps and vehicle speed setting in tune.

You biggest problem is bunderbonnet heat at low speeds in traffic, once your doing say ,60kmh plus there enough air flow to keep things cool.

Ive run uncoated header with adjusted fan settings no issues for three years


I have now made the full adjustment as per your recommendation. I had the fans to kick on at a higher temp. But I lowered it even more as per your post. The fans will now be on under 60 kmh

FISHBURGLAR 05-05-2017 09:30 AM

I found a picture of my headers the day I received them from jet hot. This is the best pic I can find actually the only one I t9ok before I installed it. I ordered from Open flash and had them shipped directly to jet hot, it was coated then shipped to me. They were coated from day 1 I got them.

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e5...ps661inzw3.png

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e5...pss7auf23t.jpg

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e5...psafrpmxc3.png

SpectreRT 05-05-2017 11:25 AM

Jethot does an awesome job; just had bad luck. Maybe its the quality of the pipe used by Shiv / Open Flash (their manufacturer).

Looks great, really sucks that happened.

FISHBURGLAR 05-05-2017 11:54 AM

It was coated with their 2500 degree ceramic coating. But what gets to me is that yes there is a wide crack, BUT the only hole is on the weld in the seam. I stuck a toothpick in there. Me and my wife hit it with a flashlight and the light went straight thru the hole at the seam of the weld. I'm no welding master, nor engineer, but the stress cracks that go to the right and left of the center hole were all caused by the hole being made where the weld was. Maybe someone can confirm this aswell i inculded a close up. Btw this header was ordered before there existed ofh2, and ofh3 .. I'm guessing I had one of the beginning headers give or take, mayhne someone else can confirm that I do have the original number.

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e5...psl0iafwxr.png

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e5...ps8681vmr8.jpg
This all happened while our temps are low. In my area. Btw I'm on long island ny... So yes we had few hot days. Yet I drive at 6 am which we have had the temps in the 50s and 40s.and I go home in the evening after sun down, again temps drop 50s 60s. I avoid most traffic jams as well I'm usually rolling never really bumped to bumper.so I do get air circulating.

Yoshoobaroo 05-05-2017 04:17 PM

Crack in My ofh
 
That pin hole is caused by a fish eye more than likely, a structural defect in the weld. The handful (3 or 4 so far, it's not a high rate) of OFH that failed in this forum have had the crack propagating in this way.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

FISHBURGLAR 05-05-2017 10:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yoshoobaroo (Post 2905135)
That pin hole is caused by a fish eye more than likely, a structural defect in the weld. The handful (3 or 4 so far, it's not a high rate) of OFH that failed in this forum have had the crack propagating in this way.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk



Thank you... this confirms my suspicion.. this is now here for future reference. Sadly I got assed out. BUT I ordered new JDL UEL headers and redoing full exhaust so better for me, even tho the pockets hurt, not an expected expense.

Confirms what the truth culprit is... this can stay for future reference.

FISHBURGLAR 05-06-2017 10:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shiv@Openflash (Post 2904483)
If you want a header to last a long time with a good quality (read: effective) thermal coating, you need to do both the interior and exterior surface. Doing just the exterior will subject it to more thermal stress than if it were uncoated. You are basically creating a thermal barrier that prevents the header to dissipate heat.

As for reported OFH failures, I can count all of them on one hand. And we have sold close to 1000 of them in the past 4 years. And most of those failures were seen on units that were stolen and sold before they even went through the QA process which means they should not have even been sold in the first place. In this case, the unit lasted 2 years despite an improper implementation of a 2800F ceramic coating.

Years ago, we sold ceramic coated headers for the Subaru 2.5RS. The only thing was that the ceramic coating wasn't very effective. it looked nice but didn't do much in the way of thermal shielding. As a result, it was a pretty benign option. These days, there are ceramic coating options that work very well. And care must be taken in using them.


Shiv, If you may read the rest of this thread. Once I receive the new header I will pull our my OFH clean off all carbon deposit and show inside and outside coating and send a video plus more pictures.

All signs to me point to a header from the bad batch. As I mostly baby the car I can see how it lasted longer to crack. Winters I don't 'll drive her.

nikitopo 05-07-2017 06:56 AM

About the topic of coating the inside of an exhaust, I'll post here the suggestions of Zircotec, which is one of the best professionals on ceramic coating:

Q28. Can you coat the inside of my exhaust? – Here at Zircotec we only apply our ceramic coating to the external surfaces. We are aware of some paint products that are applied internally. The conditions inside an exhaust manifold are quite extreme with gas at temperatures in excess of 1,000oC; pulsing gas flow of more than 20 m/sec; large pressure and temperature variations; significant vibration; and thermal stress. We are concerned that it is impossible to prepare the internal surfaces of a pipe or manifold sufficiently to receive a paint, and with such arduous operating conditions we fear that these products can easily become detached, causing serious damage to downstream components such as turbochargers and catalysts. Furthermore, these products narrow the flow channels and can restrict flow (even a thin paint can reduce the available flow area by up to 2%) giving rise to reduced engine performance. Our recommendation is that you limit any coating to just the external surfaces. You might consider polishing the internals to avoid any rough edges or corners, but our technical experts really do not advise putting any form of coating on the inside of an exhaust manifold or exhaust system.

Source here: http://www.zircotec.com/support/for-motorsport/faq/

guybo 05-07-2017 10:32 AM

What I'd be concerned about and the reason I would not get an OFH, is that there's no flex pipe of any sort. It's just common sense that if you have a rigid pipe connected to an engine that flexes (LOL, not that there's all that much torque on it!) and it extends out to the rear of the car, that something has to give.

IMHO this has nothing to do with heat stress, steel pipe can handle heat. But steel pipe is not so good with torsional and bending stresses over and over.

nikitopo 05-07-2017 11:01 AM

I agree that a correct design should have a kind of flex like the following:

http://i68.tinypic.com/2i6h2dx.jpg



or


https://image.nengun.com/catalogue/1..._flex_pipe.png

It also matters the quality of the material and the manufacturing technique.

I just posted the answer of Zircotec, to emphasize that the suggestion of coating the inside of a manifolld is not relevant and in fact can cause more problems.

Yoshoobaroo 05-07-2017 11:03 AM

Crack in My ofh
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by guybo (Post 2905951)
What I'd be concerned about and the reason I would not get an OFH, is that there's no flex pipe of any sort. It's just common sense that if you have a rigid pipe connected to an engine that flexes (LOL, not that there's all that much torque on it!)

:D lol


Quote:

and it extends out to the rear of the car, that something has to give.

IMHO this has nothing to do with heat stress, steel pipe can handle heat. But steel pipe is not so good with torsional and bending stresses over and over.


The steel is MORE than strong enough for those stresses. Steel is also very fatigue resistant for a cheap metal, even stainless (fun fact, stainless is weather than most carbon steels). The exhaust is also not rigidly mounted to the body. There's one small metallic bracket in the middle (1 bolt, so essentially a pinned connection), and flexible hangers in the back, so the exhaust can move around (and has to since the exhaust grows about 3/8ths of an inch in length when it warms up). The stock exhaust doesn't have a flex section past the header either.

Exhaust parts on street cars rarely fail from anything besides defective welds.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

churchx 05-07-2017 11:04 AM

Flex or slipjoint inserts were there on several 1st gen aftermarket headers for twins. Most of later ones hadn't such. I guess failure rate by statistics due not having them was low enough to not bother, instead simplify & cheapen manufacturing & smoothing flow, hence imho not worth to be overly concerned about them not being there.

Scrappydoo 05-07-2017 03:34 PM

Chuck it away. Re-fit the original manifold and move on.

gtengr 05-07-2017 03:35 PM

The entire exhaust is not rigidly mounted to the body, but the headers are rigidly mounted to the heads. When the car is warmed up the head flanges want to expand farther apart. Since the flanges are bolted to the head, they are restrained, and the stresses increase in the pipes. This doesn't imply that all headers without an expansion joint will fail, but that doesn't mean all headers can run without an expansion joint indefinitely without thermal cycling issues.

Heat cycling and/or vibration cause nearly all exhaust structural issues, and fatigue is the failure mode. The weld is just the location it happens. The welds are usually the failure point because the discontinuity of the joint and the HAZ are typical trouble spots for fatigue.

Yoshoobaroo 05-07-2017 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gtengr (Post 2906031)
The entire exhaust is not rigidly mounted to the body, but the headers are rigidly mounted to the heads. When the car is warmed up the head flanges want to expand farther apart. Since the flanges are bolted to the head, they are restrained, and the stresses increase in the pipes. This doesn't imply that all headers without an expansion joint will fail, but that doesn't mean all headers can run without an expansion joint indefinitely without thermal cycling issues.



Heat cycling and/or vibration cause nearly all exhaust structural issues, and fatigue is the failure mode. The weld is just the location it happens. The welds are usually the failure point because the discontinuity of the joint and the HAZ are typical trouble spots for fatigue.



Absolutely, the CTE mismatch between the aluminum motor and steel header causes the driving forces behind the header failure, but a well made header should be strong enough to withstand those for a life time 999 times it out of a 1000. I guess there will always be someone that gets unlucky and gets a bad piece.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:39 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.


Garage vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.