Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB

Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/index.php)
-   Software Tuning (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=88)
-   -   How bad is E85 in freezing winter? (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=105599)

zmz0305 05-10-2016 07:57 PM

How bad is E85 in freezing winter?
 
I have heard that it could be difficult to start the car running E85 in low temperature. But how bad could it be? Anyone had tried it before?

NyC Zn6 05-10-2016 08:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zmz0305 (Post 2648806)
I have heard that it could be difficult to start the car running E85 in low temperature. But how bad could it be? Anyone had tried it before?

Mine usually takes two tries to start in the cold. There is some fine tuning that can be done with OFT to help the cold start crank issue with e85. I haven't tried the fine tuning but updated my map couple months ago around December and it helped a lot. Now it starts on one try, don't know if Shiv made updates for the cold start with that map but it helps. Only issue I can think of is hurting the starter.

FRSBRZGT86FAN 05-10-2016 08:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zmz0305 (Post 2648806)
I have heard that it could be difficult to start the car running E85 in low temperature. But how bad could it be? Anyone had tried it before?


There are many documented cases of how e85 behaves in cold weather, this occur mainly when you get below 40-50 degrees Fahrenheit unless your tune has edited cranking tables. It takes the o2 sensors longer to heat up, in turn the car doesn't run or idle the best in cold weather until warmed up, it will crank quite a bit then finally start.

The problem with ethanol (e85) is it's "Reid Vapor pressure" (RVP), it simply does not want to vaporize below 50 degrees. Therefore it can't ignite, causing a cranking condition. It will only turn over once the combustion chamber temps get hot enough that the ethanol can vaporize.

If you have an OFT or can speak to your tuner have them apply this edit:

http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showp...1&postcount=40

As well as these cranking tables:

http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=83945

https://i.imgur.com/UliXZwz.png

Those edits should help you at above 40 degrees Fahrenheit.

phrosty 05-10-2016 09:04 PM

I ran E83 down to about 40-45 F last winter and it worked first time every time with the updated cranking tables.

Never tried going lower -- didn't want to risk stranding myself. Curious what the actual minimums are. Can probably go a lot lower by diluting with E10.

zmz0305 05-11-2016 02:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRSBRZGT86FAN (Post 2648822)
There are many documented cases of how e85 behaves in cold weather, this occur mainly when you get below 40-50 degrees Fahrenheit unless your tune has edited cranking tables. It takes the o2 sensors longer to heat up, in turn the car doesn't run or idle the best in cold weather until warmed up, it will crank quite a bit then finally start.

The problem with ethanol (e85) is it's "Reid Vapor pressure" (RVP), it simply does not want to vaporize below 50 degrees. Therefore it can't ignite, causing a cranking condition. It will only turn over once the combustion chamber temps get hot enough that the ethanol can vaporize.

If you have an OFT or can speak to your tuner have them apply this edit:

http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showp...1&postcount=40

As well as these cranking tables:

http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=83945

https://i.imgur.com/UliXZwz.png

Those edits should help you at above 40 degrees Fahrenheit.

In my area it could be 0-20F for month. I guess E85 is not recommended in that kind of condition right?

Also, what will happen if this map is used in higher temperature?

FRSBRZGT86FAN 05-11-2016 02:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zmz0305 (Post 2649055)
In my area it could be 0-20F for month. I guess E85 is not recommended in that kind of condition right?

Also, what will happen if this map is used in higher temperature?


In my area it could be 0-20F for month. I guess E85 is not recommended in that kind of condition right?

You'd honestly have to ask someone that daily's an E85 car year round in multiple temperature conditions, I only do it during spring/summer if that and only once or twice a year for shits and giggles :lol:
If running e85 is something you want you'll have to add some 93 octane (1 gallon) to the tank for those months and also use a block heater and store and start the car in a warm place. The OFT E85 tunes are good for E60-E85 I believe which is why you can add a gallon of 93 into the mix to help start-ability @steve99 could elaborate on this, I've only run e85 once or twice.

Personally as a daily driver car for me, I would never risk having start ability issues in the winter months, so I would avoid it all together below 40 degrees.

Also, what will happen if this map is used in higher temperature?
I believe it will work fine or just flash the non edited map it's that easy.

Guff 05-11-2016 03:01 AM

I've been running E85 year round in Illinois for a while and with a modified cold start injector pulse width, I can get the car to start first try in sub-30F weather. Granted, I rarely drive the car in those temperatures, but I haven't had any issues with starting. I have to do the occasional second try on some days, but most days the car starts right up.

steve99 05-11-2016 05:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRSBRZGT86FAN (Post 2649063)

In my area it could be 0-20F for month. I guess E85 is not recommended in that kind of condition right?

You'd honestly have to ask someone that daily's an E85 car year round in multiple temperature conditions, I only do it during spring/summer if that and only once or twice a year for shits and giggles :lol:
If running e85 is something you want you'll have to add some 93 octane (1 gallon) to the tank for those months and also use a block heater and store and start the car in a warm place. The OFT E85 tunes are good for E60-E85 I believe which is why you can add a gallon of 93 into the mix to help start-ability @steve99 could elaborate on this, I've only run e85 once or twice.

Personally as a daily driver car for me, I would never risk having start ability issues in the winter months, so I would avoid it all together below 40 degrees.

Also, what will happen if this map is used in higher temperature?
I believe it will work fine or just flash the non edited map it's that easy.

Use wayno s crank tables above, they will be good for starting on up to 90 percent ethanol down to about 40F first crank. then you start to run into the physical properties of ethanol not vaporizing.

Below 40F if you have high ethanol content like over 70 percent or so, your going to have to add some petrol to dilute it down to arround 70% or its just not going to start reliably below 40F


the cranking fuelling is adjusted relative to temperature (top axis of table is temperature)

Fred E 05-11-2016 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Guff (Post 2649081)
I've been running E85 year round in Illinois for a while and with a modified cold start injector pulse width, I can get the car to start first try in sub-30F weather. Granted, I rarely drive the car in those temperatures, but I haven't had any issues with starting. I have to do the occasional second try on some days, but most days the car starts right up.

I'd like to echo this; I've run E85 in the winter in New Jersey and the car has started on the first try all the way down to sub-10F weather (and probably colder). Your tune just has to be modified properly and you shouldn't have a problem.

jasonojordan 05-11-2016 11:34 AM

The key here is make sure you keep the e85 fresh. It breaks down much quicker and in the winter time this is an even bigger issue at very cold temps. That said I ran my wrx year round on e85 for 4 years. Had one time it would not start and it had sat out with a strong wind in my parents yard for a day and a half at -30 degs.

ben721364 05-11-2016 12:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zmz0305 (Post 2648806)
I have heard that it could be difficult to start the car running E85 in low temperature. But how bad could it be? Anyone had tried it before?

I can think of nothing positive to say about [corn bases] ethanol laced motor gasoline in any concentration, especially higher ones like 85%.

fumanchu1 05-11-2016 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649365)
I can think of nothing positive to say about [corn bases] ethanol laced motor gasoline in any concentration, especially higher ones like 85%.

You mean aside from more power?

jasonojordan 05-11-2016 01:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649365)
I can think of nothing positive to say about [corn bases] ethanol laced motor gasoline in any concentration, especially higher ones like 85%.

Also burns cooler so lower temps for our already borderline insufficiently cooled engines.

ben721364 05-11-2016 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fumanchu1 (Post 2649441)
You mean aside from more power?

Please provide a citation to support claim that engines burning E85 provide more power? What about fuel consumption? Manufacturing and distribution costs, ex subsidies? I am willing to be convinced?

kch 05-11-2016 02:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649492)
Please provide a citation to support claim that engines burning E85 provide more power? What about fuel consumption? Manufacturing and distribution costs, ex subsidies? I am willing to be convinced?

It's true that E85 has less energy per oz than gasoline. However, its unique properties (knock resistance, cooling effect) mean you can tune the engine to produce more power. In particular, boosted motors do exceptionally well with E85.

I won't bother getting a citation because there are probably hundreds of cars just on this forum producing more power on E85 than 93. You can look for yourself.

Edit: literally 5 seconds of googling:

Quote:

We did some testing on our turbocharged Toyota 86 and optimising the tune in the MoTeC M150 ECU netted an increase in power from the 198kW (265hp) the car made on pump gas to 267kW (358hp) at the rear wheels. Even with the high 12.5:1 compression of the FA20 engine, E85 allowed us to increase the boost from 7.0psi to 9.5 psi with no detonation. The only thing stopping us going further was the stock internals and a little mechanical sympathy.
http://www.speedhunters.com/2015/04/...about-ethanol/

ben721364 05-11-2016 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kch (Post 2649511)
It's true that E85 has less energy per oz than gasoline. However, its unique properties (knock resistance, cooling effect) mean you can tune the engine to produce more power. In particular, boosted motors do exceptionally well with E85.

I won't bother getting a citation because there are probably hundreds of cars just on this forum producing more power on E85 than 93. You can look for yourself.

I said I am willing to be convinced...

kch 05-11-2016 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649523)
I said I am willing to be convinced...

So why not do some googling yourself?

Quote:

The CCXR featured a highly modified CCX engine that ran on E85 as well as normal petrol in any mixture thanks to an advanced and Koenigsegg developed flex fuel system. When running the CCXR on petrol, the 4.7 liter twin-supercharged Koenigsegg engine delivers 806 Bhp. This already-impressive figure raised to an astonishing 1018 Bhp when the car ran on E85 Biofuel – again giving Koenigsegg the title as the world’s most powerful production car.
http://koenigsegg.com/ccxr/

Edit: this really has been discussed ad nauseam. E85 means you can run more boost, advance the timing, and produce more power without detonation. It also means roughly 33% increased fuel consumption. Generally, the price difference between E85 and 93 is offset by the increased consumption, so fuel cost is about the same overall.

jasonojordan 05-11-2016 02:47 PM

On my 02 wrx when I had it I was running 20psi on 93 and able to muster 265whp 240tq. I tuned it on e85 and went up to 24psi and the power jumped up to a even 320whp 320tq.

ben721364 05-11-2016 02:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kch (Post 2649532)
So why not do some googling yourself?



http://koenigsegg.com/ccxr/

Edit: this really has been discussed ad nauseam. E85 means you can run more boost, advance the timing, and produce more power without detonation. It also means roughly 33% increased fuel consumption. Generally, the price difference between E85 and 93 is offset by the increased consumption, so fuel cost is about the same overall.

It was my understanding that he was talking about a stock engine.

zmz0305 05-11-2016 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Guff (Post 2649081)
I've been running E85 year round in Illinois for a while and with a modified cold start injector pulse width, I can get the car to start first try in sub-30F weather. Granted, I rarely drive the car in those temperatures, but I haven't had any issues with starting. I have to do the occasional second try on some days, but most days the car starts right up.

Thanks man, that's very valuable info!

Saw your car at pizzahut yesterday:)

zmz0305 05-11-2016 03:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649568)
It was my understanding that he was talking about a stock engine.

I saw before there is a post by Shiv showing the E85 dyno result on stock engine. If I remembered correct it will be more than 10HP gain on E85 than 93. I don't remember which post it is but you could try search on forum.

Tectoniic 05-11-2016 03:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zmz0305 (Post 2649627)
I saw before there is a post by Shiv showing the E85 dyno result on stock engine. If I remembered correct it will be more than 10HP gain on E85 than 93. I don't remember which post it is but you could try search on forum.

I remember a while back as well that Delicious Tuning was able to get 200 or 201 WHP on a completely stock BRZ with an E85 tune. Granted this was a custom tune and probably quite aggressive but the ability to make power is pretty significant. I also didn't see their stock run to know if it was a relatively high or low dyno but if you figure that these cars seem to make anywhere from 156 to 176 whp stock on pump gas on dynos best case is almost a 33% power increase over stock for just switching fuel.

zmz0305 05-11-2016 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tectoniic (Post 2649640)
I remember a while back as well that Delicious Tuning was able to get 200 or 201 WHP on a completely stock BRZ with an E85 tune. Granted this was a custom tune and probably quite aggressive but the ability to make power is pretty significant. I also didn't see their stock run to know if it was a relatively high or low dyno but if you figure that these cars seem to make anywhere from 156 to 176 whp stock on pump gas on dynos best case is almost a 33% power increase over stock for just switching fuel.

I remembered it was 190ish on the E85 dyno chart and it is an old post. So I said more than 10HP because I don't really remember it. Anyway, it is free power that don't hurt anything, definitely worth a try.

fumanchu1 05-11-2016 04:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649492)
Please provide a citation to support claim that engines burning E85 provide more power? What about fuel consumption? Manufacturing and distribution costs, ex subsidies? I am willing to be convinced?

You've never seen a car run on e85 have you, look at dyno plots of the same car, same day, same dyno and observe the difference in hp/tq rating from both runs and you can come to your own conclusion (I can't spoon feed the information to you though as then you wouldn't learn as research is a very important part in retaining information... also im lazy)

jasonojordan 05-11-2016 04:07 PM

I have delicious on my brz. I have not dyno'd it to see exact gains 93 vs e85 and i do have aftermarket catback and a drop in panel filter but even so I can feel a difference in the way the car accelerates on e85 vs 93. Comes on a bit sooner and pulls just a bit harder for a bit longer then stock.

fumanchu1 05-11-2016 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649568)
It was my understanding that he was talking about a stock engine.

there's a reason why the most common bang for buck power mod is header+tune and e85 and why countless people are running their NA with headers and e85 and making great figures vs stock.

fumanchu1 05-11-2016 04:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649492)
Please provide a citation to support claim that engines burning E85 provide more power? What about fuel consumption? Manufacturing and distribution costs, ex subsidies? I am willing to be convinced?

you said you didn't see any benefits I have provided one, more power, others have provided the burns cooler also. That's 2 reasons you know of now. Whether they offset the negatives (production, etc.) is up to you but that wasn't what you asked.

FRSBRZGT86FAN 05-11-2016 04:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fumanchu1 (Post 2649668)
you said you didn't see any benefits I have provided one, more power, others have provided the burns cooler also. That's 2 reasons you know of now. Whether they offset the negatives (production, etc.) is up to you but that wasn't what you asked.

Quote:

Originally Posted by fumanchu1 (Post 2649664)
there's a reason why the most common bang for buck power mod is header+tune and e85 and why countless people are running their NA with headers and e85 and making great figures vs stock.

Quote:

Originally Posted by fumanchu1 (Post 2649655)
You've never seen a car run on e85 have you, look at dyno plots of the same car, same day, same dyno and observe the difference in hp/tq rating from both runs and you can come to your own conclusion (I can't spoon feed the information to you though as then you wouldn't learn as research is a very important part in retaining information... also im lazy)

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649568)
It was my understanding that he was talking about a stock engine.


He was definitely not talking about stock, if you can't read or absolutely disbelieve e85 you can't help in this thread, I even posted tune edits for him. What fumanchu said is correct

ben721364 05-11-2016 04:37 PM

I had no idea how passionate some of y'all are about 'corn' gas. <g>

fumanchu1 05-11-2016 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRSBRZGT86FAN (Post 2649677)
He was definitely not talking about stock, if you can't read or absolutely disbelieve e85 you can't help in this thread, I even posted tune edits for him. What fumanchu said is correct

What's a stock car? You mean those big drag racers?! :)

ben721364 05-11-2016 04:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fumanchu1 (Post 2649708)
What's a stock car? You mean those big drag racers?! :)

I initially responded to post #1. Nothing that I saw in it indicated that the OP was referring to a modified engine.

Y'all have fun. <G>

fumanchu1 05-11-2016 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649716)
I initially responded to post #1. Nothing that I saw in it indicated that the OP was referring to a modified engine.

Y'all have fun. <G>

I actually don't like e85 as I feel the negatives outweigh the benefits when looked at globally, a lot more if you take other alternative fuels into consideration.


That being said, if I was looking to squeeze every little hp out of my engine then e85 would be in the tank but with my current setup I don't need more power and am not tuned for e85

Tectoniic 05-11-2016 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ben721364 (Post 2649707)
I had no idea how passionate some of y'all are about 'corn' gas. <g>

Gotta tell everyone about the corn juice. :thumbsup:
Why else would I carry my giant ear of corn around all day?
https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com...9d4a834035.jpg

orangespark 05-11-2016 06:35 PM

I was just about to ask why E85 would be an issue. I always figured Ethanol vaporized more readily than fuel. Gotta go back to basics I guess :)

steve99 05-11-2016 07:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by orangespark (Post 2649817)
I was just about to ask why E85 would be an issue. I always figured Ethanol vaporized more readily than fuel. Gotta go back to basics I guess :)


Flash Point




Gasoline (petrol)−43 °C (−45 °F)Ethyl Alcohol, Ethanol 17 C (63F)

WRBrzRX 05-12-2016 01:18 PM

I never had to attempt to start it more than once in the 50s and 60s F* but it certainly had a lumpy idle for ~10 sec

it certainly feels like race gas but the new 93 tune is close so I'm happy with it (mostly about lack of pumps around here)


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:10 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.


Garage vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.