Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB

Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/index.php)
-   Engine, Exhaust, Transmission (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   I need help on which ecutek I should get, stg 1 or 2 (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=32261)

Frsexxxy 03-29-2013 02:37 AM

I need help on which ecutek I should get, stg 1 or 2
 
This is what I have done to my car so far, front pipe, mid, pipe second cat delete, dual muffler exhaust. And injen intake. And I would like to know the hp and torque gains in these.

BuBlake 03-29-2013 02:55 AM

:popcorn:

Hawaiian 03-29-2013 04:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frsexxxy (Post 826448)
This is what I have done to my car so far, front pipe, mid, pipe second cat delete, dual muffler exhaust. And injen intake. And I would like to know the hp and torque gains in these.

Intake and or header usually = stg 2. Header back or less is stg 1.

DSOmegaX 03-29-2013 04:18 AM

No intake = stage 1, intake = stage 2

Calum 03-29-2013 06:26 AM

Visconti

RandomHero 03-29-2013 07:45 AM

This thread makes me sad :(

Is the search button missing in some browsers?

Huehuecoyotl 03-29-2013 09:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RandomHero (Post 826619)
This thread makes me sad :(

Is the search button missing in some browsers?

x2

industrial 03-29-2013 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RandomHero (Post 826619)
This thread makes me sad :(

Is the search button missing in some browsers?

People should have to lurk for a few days before being able to post these inane questions in the tech sections. I think I lurked for about a year here before I posted anything. Same at every forum I've ever been to. I think we're going to be flooded with questions like these as the weather gets nicer and more cars sell.

Foobar 03-29-2013 10:26 AM

Putting the whole search first issue aside, there's also the other problem of ECUTek "stages" meaning different things to different ECUTek vendors. FA20Club's "Stage 2", for example, was tweaked for the aFe Takeda intake (perhaps others as well). Perrin and Visconti, on the other hand, have done similar things and still consider it part of their "Stage 1".

Bottom line - go with whichever ECUTek vendor you feel good about, they will all accomplish the performance gains. Ideally, you'd want someone local to you so you can have them Dyno tune if you want to get every possible last drop out of it. If there isn't one local, then go by pricing and customer service response. All of the ECUTek tuners on this forum have received favorable customer service feedback. I personally have tunes from Visconti and Perrin, and while both can be very busy at times, they have always responded to requests I've made. With recent resource additions and big projects out of the way, both have been very easy to work with lately. I can't speak for the others, but I've had good communications experience with FA20Club as well, even though I don't have his tune, and he has a strong following here on the forum.

Saab2Frs 03-29-2013 10:45 AM

I remember these posts from the Saabcentral forums. BSR vs Vtuner vs JZW vs Maptun. How much fun those were to read, but that was dealing with turbos, which, when tuned, could net you an extra 40bhp and gobs of lb/ft.

Go FA20Club. After reading some posts about how bolt-ons gain you nothing, I was concerned that I had bought a full exhaust system and intake for little to no gains. He took the time to explain why that explanation was right and why it was wrong. I just got the tune files in my email today and I will be installing it tonight!

Word of warning, though. FA20 is VERY busy and is a one man show, so don't be surprised if there are some delays in getting your cables and such.

AllDayJonRay 03-29-2013 11:13 AM

As others have already said, all of our EcuTek vendors seem to have different criteria for what determines Stage 1 or Stage 2.

I believe FA20Club says their Stage 1 is for completely stock cars only, and even basic bolt-on cars get Stage 2. E85 tunes must be purchased separately.

Visconti's Stage 1 tune is for all bolt-on only cars, minus E85 users. For E85 tunes, similar to FA20Club, you will have to buy a second map.

Moto-East on the other hand seems to have more of a 'tuning is tuning' philosophy, as their kit includes tuning for ANY level (or combination) of NA modification, including E85, if desired..

http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=31010
Best Deal for an EcuTek tune currently available. So far, @moto-mike has been very communicative with me to address my questions and concerns, more than other vendors. That, and the fact that he is within driving distance for me is what made my decision to go with him.

He is the only vendor that has made a detailed video explanation of what your RaceRom features actually are, which is a huge plus. Oh, and he responds to inquiries with more than three word answers, which makes you feel more like he is actually answering your question, and not blowing you off, or hiding "future update secrets".

There is less feedback for Moto East on this board (compared to the other vendors), since he hasn't been in the 86 market as long. He does have a good history in servicing the Mazda (MX-5 & Turbo Mazda models) communities, and I have yet to hear anything bad regarding his tunes or service.

I don't know about any of the other EcuTek vendors, as I haven't researched.

I hope this helps clear up your question regarding which "stage" tune you need.

BTW, I learned all this by using the :search: function, and rummaging around for information...

Huehuecoyotl 03-29-2013 02:26 PM

Mods need to close lock and delete these threads, and refer noobs to existing info, this is a waste of resource. I am sure we could benefit a USE THE SEARCH sticky

Craig 03-29-2013 03:00 PM

I vote for a screening process for new members, basically rather than their posts showing up they must get approved by a moderator until they have x posts. Maybe enslave a team of us frequent posters *raises hand* to be a screeners. With the summer coming I don't want the nature of this form to be people saying "SEARCH BAR NOOB" and "What X should I buy" "Can I use 87 Octane?" "WTF is a TUNE and how do i get one?"

I'd be willing to screen like I said to try to keep it civil here. We've got one of the better forum communities out there, I'd like to see it stay that way.

AllDayJonRay 03-29-2013 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Craig (Post 827394)
I vote for a screening process for new members, basically rather than their posts showing up they must get approved by a moderator until they have x posts. Maybe enslave a team of us frequent posters *raises hand* to be a screeners. With the summer coming I don't want the nature of this form to be people saying "SEARCH BAR NOOB" and "What X should I buy" "Can I use 87 Octane?" "WTF is a TUNE and how do i get one?"

I'd be willing to screen like I said to try to keep it civil here. We've got one of the better forum communities out there, I'd like to see it stay that way.

:word: I'm on board with this. Only issue is, with the 86 platform gaining popularity, there are likely to be MANY new members registering each week. To screen each of those new members posts may take some excessive resources. That said, sign me up as well. I'll gladly screen new members threads. It would definitely keep the forum from going in the wrong direction, help keep vital information in ONE thread instead of reposted hundreds of times (which ruins the search functionality), and likely stop many a flame war from happening.

mike_ekim1024 03-29-2013 03:26 PM

Isn't this a prime candidate for a sticky thread with answers from people who have flashed their ECU and confirmed it works with certain mods?

jwjknorr 03-29-2013 03:27 PM

Its really not that big of a deal guys. its kbs of data , txt, and some threads get to long and annoying to read. I find it funny, if it bothers you ignore it, why care so much?

Hawaiian 03-29-2013 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AllDayJonRay (Post 826863)
As others have already said, all of our EcuTek vendors seem to have different criteria for what determines Stage 1 or Stage 2.

I believe FA20Club says their Stage 1 is for completely stock cars only, and even basic bolt-on cars get Stage 2. E85 tunes must be purchased separately.

If you only want an e85 tune you can get that only. It's not required to get the pumpgas tune then an 85 tune. I've helped local guys with their @FA20Club.com e85 only tune. He sent them the basemap, and tweaked their files within an hour.

Visconti's Stage 1 tune is for all bolt-on only cars, minus E85 users. For E85 tunes, similar to FA20Club, you will have to buy a second map.

The @Visconti tune supports all mods as well, you just need to datalog and send him the files. I don't know his average turnaround now that he's added another staff member.

Moto-East on the other hand seems to have more of a 'tuning is tuning' philosophy, as their kit includes tuning for ANY level (or combination) of NA modification, including E85, if desired..

All of the tuners on this board follow this philosophy. They have built basemaps, and will tweak it for your car based on logs, also modifying tunes as you get new parts.

http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=31010
Best Deal for an EcuTek tune currently available. So far, @moto-mike has been very communicative with me to address my questions and concerns, more than other vendors. That, and the fact that he is within driving distance for me is what made my decision to go with him.

He is the only vendor that has made a detailed video explanation of what your RaceRom features actually are, which is a huge plus. Oh, and he responds to inquiries with more than three word answers, which makes you feel more like he is actually answering your question, and not blowing you off, or hiding "future update secrets".

Flat out untrue. @Visconti had posted several videos of the features as Ecutek released them to the vendors. They are just buried in his thread.

There is less feedback for Moto East on this board (compared to the other vendors), since he hasn't been in the 86 market as long. He does have a good history in servicing the Mazda (MX-5 & Turbo Mazda models) communities, and I have yet to hear anything bad regarding his tunes or service.

I don't know about any of the other EcuTek vendors, as I haven't researched.

I hope this helps clear up your question regarding which "stage" tune you need.

BTW, I learned all this by using the :search: function, and rummaging around for information...

There are some pretty broad and untrue generalizations in that post.

Visconti posting Flat foot shifting back in August
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BgZtR_Of85Y"]EcuTek RaceRom Flat-Foot Shifting for BRZ/FRS - YouTube[/ame]

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lSHFMFUGCMQ"][/ame]

Craig 03-29-2013 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AllDayJonRay (Post 827459)
:word: I'm on board with this. Only issue is, with the 86 platform gaining popularity, there are likely to be MANY new members registering each week. To screen each of those new members posts may take some excessive resources. That said, sign me up as well. I'll gladly screen new members threads. It would definitely keep the forum from going in the wrong direction, help keep vital information in ONE thread instead of reposted hundreds of times (which ruins the search functionality), and likely stop many a flame war from happening.

I have no problem spending some time sorting through posts. I just don't think we're going down the right path right now as a community. Would hate to see this end up like vwvortex which is a massive shit show imho.

AllDayJonRay 03-29-2013 03:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hawaiian (Post 827480)
There are some pretty broad and untrue generalizations in that post.

"If you only want an e85 tune you can get that only. It's not required to get the pumpgas tune then an 85 tune. I've helped local guys with their @FA20Club.com e85 only tune. He sent them the basemap, and tweaked their files within an hour."

My statement is not untrue in any sense. If you want a pump gas tune, as well as an E85 tune, you must purchase TWO separate tunes. I never said you couldn't ONLY get an E85 for the cost of one tune. I hadn't thought of that possibility, as I imagine most members are not running solely E85 (considering its limited availability), and would want a 91/93 tune as well..

Quote:

"The @Visconti tune supports all mods as well, you just need to datalog and send him the files. I don't know his average turnaround now that he's added another staff member."
Is it just me, or is that what I said? Visconti's Stage 1 tune supports all "bolt-on" cars (hence, there is no "Stage 2"), but again, E85 requires purchase of another tune. Opposed to FA20Club, which uses 'separate' (stage 1 or 2) tunes for stock vs bolt-on cars.

Quote:

All of the tuners on this board follow this philosophy. They have built basemaps, and will tweak it for your car based on logs, also modifying tunes as you get new parts.
Please take into context exactly what point I was making:
FA20: Stock vs. modified cars are separate tune files (stage 1 vs 2), E85 is also separate.
Visconti: Stage 1 covers stock & bolt-on cars, but E85 requires separate purchase.
Moto-East: One purchase gets you tuned, regardless of the extent of your bolt-ons, and includes E85, should you desire it.

I guess my mistake was not mentioning that ALL vendors will collect datalogs for your car and optimize your tune for you.

Quote:

Flat out untrue. @Visconti had posted several videos of the features as Ecutek released them to the vendors. They are just buried in his thread.
Absolutely my mistake. Through all my searches, I had not seen those videos posted to the board. That supports my point made here:
Quote:

...help keep vital information in ONE thread instead of reposted hundreds of times (which ruins the search functionality),...

Hawaiian 03-29-2013 04:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AllDayJonRay (Post 827564)
My statement is not untrue in any sense. If you want a pump gas tune, as well as an E85 tune, you must purchase TWO separate tunes. I never said you couldn't ONLY get an E85 for the cost of one tune. I hadn't thought of that possibility, as I imagine most members are not running solely E85 (considering its limited availability), and would want a 91/93 tune as well..


Is it just me, or is that what I said? Visconti's Stage 1 tune supports all "bolt-on" cars (hence, there is no "Stage 2"), but again, E85 requires purchase of another tune. Opposed to FA20Club, which uses 'separate' (stage 1 or 2) tunes for stock vs bolt-on cars.

I guess it was the way you phrased it made me think something else, much like the Fa20club phrasing. If you get the tune when you are stock, and then add intake etc, they will tweak your tune to the "stage 2" level without any additional fees.

Please take into context exactly what point I was making:
FA20: Stock vs. modified cars are separate tune files (stage 1 vs 2), E85 is also separate.
Visconti: Stage 1 covers stock & bolt-on cars, but E85 requires separate purchase.
Moto-East: One purchase gets you tuned, regardless of the extent of your bolt-ons, and includes E85, should you desire it.

No additional charge for the E85 tune is pretty big imho. That's a 200-300$ saving vs every other vendor. Here in the Midwest it's the E85 capitol of the Us.

I guess my mistake was not mentioning that ALL vendors will collect datalogs for your car and optimize your tune for you.


Absolutely my mistake. Through all my searches, I had not seen those videos posted to the board. That supports my point made here:

We all make mistakes. I misunderstood some of your post as well. Glad you enjoy the tune, and that's the most important thing.

AllDayJonRay 03-29-2013 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hawaiian (Post 827629)
We all make mistakes. I misunderstood some of your post as well. Glad you enjoy the tune, and that's the most important thing.

Haven't received my tune yet. But very much looking forward to it!

I wish E85 was viable for me (the only gas station I know of that has it is a good 40 minute drive from my house, in a direction I rarely travel in).

feldy 03-29-2013 08:41 PM

Another cool thing about @FA20Club.com you can get both tunes for only 400 bucks or 3 tunes for 450. First tune 300 next is 100 and the 3rd 50 bucks if you need a 3rd.

I run the stage 1 pump gas with a avo silicone tube/trd drop in filter. And e85 tune.

FA20Club.com 03-29-2013 11:45 PM

wow this was easily thrown off course. if you have any questions regarding my person strategy for separate tunes feel free to pm me


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:30 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2026 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.


Garage vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.