Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB

Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/index.php)
-   Tracking / Autocross / HPDE / Drifting (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=39)
-   -   Replacement rotors/pads for StopTech BBK (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=139847)

colobrio 04-13-2020 07:21 PM

Replacement rotors/pads for StopTech BBK
 
Howdy. I picked up an STX-modified BRZ this past winter, primarily for AutoX but also track fun. I got in exactly one day of each before everything shut down.

The car came with a StopTech BBK in front, 328mm rotors. The rotors and pads both need replacing.

(1) Rotors - This is my first experience with aftermarket brakes, and I was surprised (understatement) to learn that replacement rotor rings from StopTech will cost about $675 for the pair. Are there any alternatives?

(2) Pads - Can anyone point me to a list of available replacement pads (assuming anyone other than StopTech makes pads to fit)? I'm not necessarily opposed to StopTech, I would just like to know what options I've got. I've already put DS2500s in the back.

Cheers.

FastWhite 04-13-2020 07:37 PM

Check on Counter Space Garage web page. Best selection of brake pads I have found.
Rotors, I don’t know.
Check on their website.
Cheers


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

NoHaveMSG 04-13-2020 07:52 PM

I have the same setup, the biggest downside is the cost of the friction rings. The friction rings go on sale every now and then, I got a set off rallysportdirect 20% off and set them aside. I have done 3 years on mine and they are just getting to the point I will likely need to replace them the end of this year.

I have been running the CSG C1 pad front and rear and I am very happy with them except, they wear the rotors a lot in cold weather. So for street driving I would recommend swapping them for a street pad.

14stu 04-13-2020 09:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by colobrio (Post 3319391)
Thanks, all for the quick replies.



Basically, I'm looking for a good AutoX pad that, compared to other good AutoX pads, will hold up relatively well during a 30 minute track session (open lapping, hopefully an occasional TT). And yes, I realize "relatively well" won't be nearly as well as a dedicated track pad, but, 30 minutes.

I like the Ferodo pads, the DS1.11 are my favorite (I haven't tried their newest pad, DS3.12). The DS2500 is more autox focused and will hold up at the track, but if you are fast enough, they wear faster due to heat (they don't get to the point of fade but the wear is accelerated). The DS1.11 works for both autox and track, you won't overheat it easily and it works straight away for autox (not a bad idea to drag the brakes on the way to the start line for the first run, but they'll work just fine). The DSUNO is a little more track focused and ramps up with temperature more than the other pads (starts out pretty high and just gets better), so it's the least autox friendly but I've used them at autox without any real issues.

If you don't like Ferodo, the Hawks DTC30 is very similar to the DS2500, the DTC60 is the DSUNO equivalent, and the DTC70 is a track pad that won't heat up for autox but bites hard once up to temperature.

I've daily driven all these options except the DTC70 (I've got a 6mi commute, track or autox every weekend that's not shutdown for the pandemic, and don't mind the noise) but I've also had people literally pull forwards a car length when I brake behind them at stoplights.

colobrio 04-13-2020 11:15 PM

For anyone who comes here with the same questions, I think I found an an answer to the second. I can't say if it's comprehensive, but it's got a lot of options: https://www.zeckhausen.com/catalog/i...k6mr64adslshp7

colobrio 04-13-2020 11:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 14stu (Post 3319425)
I like the Ferodo pads, the DS1.11 are my favorite (I haven't tried their newest pad, DS3.12). The DS2500 is more autox focused and will hold up at the track, but if you are fast enough, they wear faster due to heat (they don't get to the point of fade but the wear is accelerated). The DS1.11 works for both autox and track, you won't overheat it easily and it works straight away for autox (not a bad idea to drag the brakes on the way to the start line for the first run, but they'll work just fine). The DSUNO is a little more track focused and ramps up with temperature more than the other pads (starts out pretty high and just gets better), so it's the least autox friendly but I've used them at autox without any real issues.

If you don't like Ferodo, the Hawks DTC30 is very similar to the DS2500, the DTC60 is the DSUNO equivalent, and the DTC70 is a track pad that won't heat up for autox but bites hard once up to temperature.

I've daily driven all these options except the DTC70 (I've got a 6mi commute, track or autox every weekend that's not shutdown for the pandemic, and don't mind the noise) but I've also had people literally pull forwards a car length when I brake behind them at stoplights.


Thanks, 14STU, that's helpful. I'll probably go with the DS 2500. Thoughts: AutoX is the priority, at least after avoiding fade; the track may get squeezed out a bit this year, to make room for more AutoX in a shortened season; and the local track has straights of 2,800' and 1,400', which I think helps with the brake temps a bit.

14stu 04-14-2020 12:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by colobrio (Post 3319490)
Thanks, 14STU, that's helpful. I'll probably go with the DS 2500. Thoughts: AutoX is the priority, at least after avoiding fade; the track may get squeezed out a bit this year, to make room for more AutoX in a shortened season; and the local track has straights of 2,800' and 1,400', which I think helps with the brake temps a bit.

Longer straights also mean higher top speeds which add heat (heat is proportional to the speed squared, so doubling the speed increases the heat generated by four times). The DS 2500 should work great for you, just keep an eye on wear at the track. I was getting about 3-4 days out of the DS 2500 while the DS1.11 would last 6-7 on average (my one day events usually have 5-7 twenty minute sessions and I'm out for all of them, it's not uncommon for me to see 3hrs of track time in a day so calibrate to your experience but be ready for the pads to wear a bit fast so at worst you're pleasantly surprised that they exceeded your expectations rather than running out of pad and needing to go home early).

I always like to have a fresh set on standby, but before the mess I was scheduled for 40 trackdays. I'm hoping to still get in more than last year (32 plus 11 autox events), but that's starting to look unlikely (I only got in 7 days before lockdown).

M0nk3y 04-14-2020 09:37 AM

Personally, especially since you have BBKs up front. Get brake pads for AutoX and for the Track.

The DS2500s and DS1.11s are compound cross compatible, so you won't run into issues there. You'll be able to run the 2500s in the rear and still be okay, but at least have 1.11s up front.

Molez93 04-14-2020 02:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by M0nk3y (Post 3319605)
Personally, especially since you have BBKs up front. Get brake pads for AutoX and for the Track.

The DS2500s and DS1.11s are compound cross compatible, so you won't run into issues there. You'll be able to run the 2500s in the rear and still be okay, but at least have 1.11s up front.


Ditto, at least to the general recommendation. Any time I've tried to just run autocross friendly pads at the track I regret the compromised stopping power- doesn't matter what car. Similarly, living with true track pads on the street is torture: bad performance, crummy noise.

colobrio 04-15-2020 02:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Molez93 (Post 3319702)
Ditto, at least to the general recommendation. Any time I've tried to just run autocross friendly pads at the track I regret the compromised stopping power- doesn't matter what car. Similarly, living with true track pads on the street is torture: bad performance, crummy noise.

I understand re: separate pads. I also suspect that if I have to swap pads twice for every trip to the track, I'm going to wind up going to the track less often. If I'm unhappy with the pads the next time out, I can also get a set of 1.11s then. Otherwise, I'm willing to give up a little, for convenience. This hobby is plenty time consuming as it is.

ZDan 04-15-2020 02:52 PM

Ive never had any issues running Carbotech XP8s, XP10s, and PFC 11 pads on the street and at the track for whole track seasons. I haven't swapped pads before/after events for *years*.

NoHaveMSG 04-15-2020 04:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZDan (Post 3320078)
Ive never had any issues running Carbotech XP8s, XP10s, and PFC 11 pads on the street and at the track for whole track seasons. I haven't swapped pads before/after events for *years*.

But XP10's suck.

ZDan 04-15-2020 05:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoHaveMSG (Post 3320127)
But XP10's suck.

Pad selection is *very* driver specific. I never had any issues running XP10s on the 255rwhp 240z or 550hp FD. I would prefer more bite, but they never failed me once, and lasted a decent amount of time, and were pretty streetable. For *me*...

NoHaveMSG 04-15-2020 07:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZDan (Post 3320154)
Pad selection is *very* driver specific. I never had any issues running XP10s on the 255rwhp 240z or 550hp FD. I would prefer more bite, but they never failed me once, and lasted a decent amount of time, and were pretty streetable. For *me*...

Even on a track day that was damp and there where rain showers they would smear on the rotors. They are also loud as hell on the street.

ZDan 04-15-2020 07:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoHaveMSG (Post 3320175)
Even on a track day that was damp and there where rain showers they would smear on the rotors. They are also loud as hell on the street.

I never had any issues at the track. Once beaten into submission they didn't make what I considered unacceptable noise on the street. Some noise, yes, but I could live with it.

They worked for me, they'll work for others, but obviously they don't work for everybody. Again, brake pad optimization is going to be *very* driver-dependent.

gcranston 04-16-2020 01:22 AM

Dan, you've got the noisiest brakes in the paddock! Or was that the Winmax?

ZDan 04-16-2020 08:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gcranston (Post 3320280)
Dan, you've got the noisiest brakes in the paddock! Or was that the Winmax?

Those were Winmax W5s. I loved those pads *except* for the noise! Yeah, it's saying something when you're at the track with a bunch of seasoned trackhounds and heads are turning in astounded wonder at the brake noise :eyebulge: Woulda been my go-to pads except for that. Great modulation, great initial bite, high c.f., work when cold, good life. But DAMN at the noise... At the track who cares, but I tend to drive on the street with track pads all season...

M0nk3y 04-16-2020 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by colobrio (Post 3320068)
I understand re: separate pads. I also suspect that if I have to swap pads twice for every trip to the track, I'm going to wind up going to the track less often. If I'm unhappy with the pads the next time out, I can also get a set of 1.11s then. Otherwise, I'm willing to give up a little, for convenience. This hobby is plenty time consuming as it is.

Just IMO and my $0.02, YMMV...

If you're touching every brake caliper (as you should for a pre-track day shakedown) and bleeding fluid...the extra effort to swap a brake pad on BBK calipers shouldn't be a second thought.

While I realize DS2500s "should" be okay, they are far from ideal. Like anything else, I see it as a safety perspective running proper pads and not compromising.

If you think this is too much work, perhaps you should re-evaluate the hobby. Tough words to swallow, but just my opinion.

NoHaveMSG 04-16-2020 12:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZDan (Post 3320186)
I never had any issues at the track. Once beaten into submission they didn't make what I considered unacceptable noise on the street. Some noise, yes, but I could live with it.

They worked for me, they'll work for others, but obviously they don't work for everybody. Again, brake pad optimization is going to be *very* driver-dependent.

Maybe I got a shit set or something :iono:

I tried adjusting my braking, no dice. I just find it odd I could smear them on a damp track where I was not driving them that hard. On a hot day I could smear the rears too. I had better performance out of PMU HC800's on my stock calipers.

gcranston 04-16-2020 12:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZDan (Post 3320319)
but I tend to drive on the street with track pads all season...


I thought you specifically got the PP so you could replace pads without opening the calipers?

ZDan 04-16-2020 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoHaveMSG (Post 3320368)
Maybe I got a shit set or something :iono:

Could be... Or actual pad compound not matching the box? I think the XP10s are painted gold IIRC?

Quote:

I tried adjusting my braking, no dice.
Yeah, if you have to "adjust your braking", that ain't right...

Quote:

I just find it odd I could smear them on a damp track where I was not driving them that hard. On a hot day I could smear the rears too. I had better performance out of PMU HC800's on my stock calipers.
Weird for sure. I must have run ~10+ sets over the years between the 240Z and RX-7 and never had any issues. I ran XP8s on the S2000 over the years, likewise never any problems at all with braking, and maybe a little more streetable fwiw. For XP10 and XP8 both I would prefer a bit more initial bite and slightly higher c.f. for less pedal effort required, but they never ever failed me and were IMO quite streetable even DD'ing for months on end.

It has been a few years since I ran Carbotechs, I wonder if compounds or processes have changed?

NoHaveMSG 04-16-2020 01:31 PM

Replacement rotors/pads for StopTech BBK
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ZDan (Post 3320394)
Could be... Or actual pad compound not matching the box? I think the XP10s are painted gold IIRC?



Yeah, if you have to "adjust your braking", that ain't right...







Weird for sure. I must have run ~10+ sets over the years between the 240Z and RX-7 and never had any issues. I ran XP8s on the S2000 over the years, likewise never any problems at all with braking, and maybe a little more streetable fwiw. For XP10 and XP8 both I would prefer a bit more initial bite and slightly higher c.f. for less pedal effort required, but they never ever failed me and were IMO quite streetable even DD'ing for months on end.



It has been a few years since I ran Carbotechs, I wonder if compounds or processes have changed?



The backing plate on mine where red.



Yeah I don't know. I have spoken with plenty of people who have had good luck with the XP8's and 10's. I just could not get them to work well for me at all performance wise and mechanically.

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/202...ef191b2297.jpg

ZDan 04-16-2020 01:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gcranston (Post 3320384)
I thought you specifically got the PP so you could replace pads without opening the calipers?

Yes. Wanted leather/alcantara anyway, so PP at just $1200 more made sense anyway even if only for styleee points, but hate hate hate changing pads on sliding calipers. Even if I only do it 2-3 times a year...

ZDan 04-16-2020 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NoHaveMSG (Post 3320396)
The backing plate on mine where red.

I mighta been thinking about the Winmax being gold....

Dunno why your results were so poor, again I haven't run them in several years but when I did, on a car more than 10 seconds faster than the BRZ at Watkins Glen, no probs...

Racecomp Engineering 04-16-2020 03:56 PM

The range in experiences from people on Carbotechs is pretty broad IMO.

- Andrew


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:46 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2026 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.


Garage vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.