Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB

Toyota GR86, 86, FR-S and Subaru BRZ Forum & Owners Community - FT86CLUB (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/index.php)
-   Software Tuning (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=88)
-   -   E85 Overrun Pops & Fire on NA (https://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=129251)

erebuswarrior 07-28-2018 01:05 AM

E85 Overrun Pops & Fire on NA
 
2 Attachment(s)
After tuning for quite a few CALID's of the 86 community I now have a better understanding of my version of pops and bangs. You'll want to edit mainly 3 things. Overrun Enrich RPM Delta: This is the amount of RPM drop that needs to happen for Overrun to start. (I use -1, change to whatever RPM you want it to drop by before engaging enrichment) Overrun Initial Injector Enrichment Pulsewidth (I have used anywhere from 0.8 up to 8.8ms) and Base Timing Idle In-Gear Above Speed Threshold (So far in the 176 coolant temp row, -12.97 at 1500RPM to 1800RPM seems to be the right amount of timing for pops/bangs and for those with catless setups, fire.) Make sure you use the fixed xml definition files that are here on the forums for v4.03 OFT tunes. There are some xml files provided by OFT that may not have been fixed yet, that have errors in it, and it will make the In Gear Above Speed Threshold table look way different then it should be.

For those who have issues with throttle delay, either use Pulsewidth's closer to 0.0 or turn it off completely. Long pulse width's like 8.8ms can cause issues with throttle delay especially after lots of pops, but you need to give it some time for fuel trims and the accelerator pedal deadspace to go away. It takes about 50-100 miles of driving in closed loop learning mode before fuel trims settle and throttle dead space goes away. After at least 100 miles of driving, it should be much easier to rev match and throttle delay should not be as much. There will inherently be some delay afterwards and this is because it is using negative timing and a richer mixture at the exhaust cycle. You can't make power with negative timing, only with advanced timing. There are tradeoff's of course, and this is why there's the jerkiness with the traditional B-Timing table pops, since that table directly influences power. In Gear Timing tables luckily don't cause jerkiness on/off throttle. If you can't get used to pressing in the accelerator pedal more for rev matching or the throttle delay is too much, then don't use overrun, just In Gear Timing.

CALID's that aren't compatible are pretty much all Auto trans versions. If you make these changes on a auto trans version, autorev matching when using paddle shifters or gear shifter in manual mode, will NOT work. This is because the auto trans ecm gets confused by the negative timing with In Gear table. Manual users shouldn't be affected by this.

Ecutek users:
I currently have Ecutek RaceRom v9 and using Ecutek's autorev match function on manual with In Gear Above Speed Threshold negative timing, DOES work. So Ecutek users can use the same method on manual trans. I have yet to test on Ecutek with auto trans.
There is only 1 Overrun table in Ecutek, and it is for injector's kicking back on at certain RPM's. There are none of the Overrun tables you see below in Ecutek unfortunately.

Link to, how to fix xml file's.
http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=126180

I'm on Ecutek and when I want to run afterfire this is my rescaled table on Ecutek.

fr-steezz 09-20-2018 03:34 PM

You figure it out?

FRSBRZGT86FAN 09-21-2018 01:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by erebuswarrior (Post 3115351)
I've been doing a lot of research and testing trying to figure out the best way to get pops+fire out the exhaust on NA FRS/BRZ/86's. I know it's pretty easy to do on FI with overrun but I won't be going FI for awhile. So far I've found I like overrun logic pops way better then editing base timing b. That lurching motion is awful and overrun=downshift rev matching pops is perfect lol. I've noticed that changing pulse width influences how it pops. 0.8ms is the easiest to get to pop and is pretty sharp all the time. Going to 1.8ms, to 2.8ms, it can be harder to do on demand but you can get some nice ones when downshift rev matching. I'll link a photo to what I'm currently running. Just looking to see if anyone has ideas on how to elicit fire and maybe get this to work with LC like a faux antilag? I know again in FI you can get 2 step antilag systems that pop and make good flames, but I want to see how close we can get to that on NA. Hoping this will be purely productive, I get there's the whole "why do that, why do this" side of the fence, and my goal isn't to argue about pops vs no pops. This isn't just for me, it's to help the BRZ/FRS/86 community in general for those who are interested in this kind of tune add on.

UPDATE 1:
So I've been spending time messing around with what works and doesn't work. If anyone checks back on this thread just know I'm still working on figuring it out since I can't find anyone to spill the beans lol. The below values are no longer anywhere near what I'm using now to achieve decent flames, these are the tables I've been messing with however just different values. Next I'll be figuring out what fueling tables to changed that will only hopefully affect fueling during overrun. I'll update this thread once I've figured it out.

Quote:

Originally Posted by fr-steezz (Post 3135616)
You figure it out?


I'm interested if this ended up working as well. Although I already had my fun with the pops and bangs tune edits on 93 and wouldn't put it on e85, I'm very interested on whether or not it worked. Also e85 is worse mpg as it is, I wonder how much of a hit this added as well.

Chuckls 09-23-2018 09:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by erebuswarrior (Post 3136551)
I've actually gotten it figured out and found the sweet spots. MPG isn't that different. maybe 1/4 a gallon of MPG difference at max? It's pretty much indiscernible. Throwing much larger flames on 91/93 then E85 of course. No stupid jerkiness with overrun pops that you would get with just editing B Timing Table. I think on 91/93, catless headers, catless aftermarket, or catted OEM front pipe, getting about 2-4 foot flames or so. E85 is about half that, sometimes 3.

Care to update post with maps?

Somerandom18 09-27-2018 02:56 PM

Overrun always causes rev hang or sometimes even auto rev matching type effect when I try it..

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

erebuswarrior 03-19-2019 10:59 PM

Post has been updated everyone. Sorry it took so long to kinda finalize this, but I didn't want to post my finding until I had tuned enough different CALID's to see what works and what doesn't.

steve99 03-20-2019 05:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by erebuswarrior (Post 3197994)
Post has been updated everyone. Sorry it took so long to kinda finalize this, but I didn't want to post my finding until I had tuned enough different CALID's to see what works and what doesn't.


If you want to incorporste the tables defined in romraider in ecutek tune.


Start with stock rom ( one without lc\ffs patch)
Edit this stock rom with romraider to add the undefined changes
Save editied rom then open it with ecutek
Then make any other changes you need then add ecutek racerom if needed


If you dont want to add reaceom you can just use a rom with patches, but make sure its a narive rom and not calid hacked. The calid hacks or lc\ffs patch will conduse ecutek and also stop you lading racerom patch

Chuckls 03-20-2019 05:01 PM

Can confirm this works better than the jerky tune.

elBarto 03-21-2019 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by erebuswarrior (Post 3197994)
Post has been updated everyone. Sorry it took so long to kinda finalize this, but I didn't want to post my finding until I had tuned enough different CALID's to see what works and what doesn't.

If you want even more control, you can rescale that table to get more rpm's
It's basicly grouping all of the same values in to one table to gain 3 more tables.

https://images2.imgbox.com/02/db/HyGdbskr_o.png
(These are settings for a daily driver, just some light added burble)

erebuswarrior 03-23-2019 04:53 PM

Was thinking about trying that a long time ago, but never got around to testing it on my own BRZ so I never did that for anyone else. I don't use anyone I tune's twins as guinea pigs so I test on mine first. I'm on Ecutek now, I might give this a try. Didn't want to risk bricking my ECU when I first started with In Gear pops testing over a year ago, so I never tried rescaling stuff like that.

Chuckls 03-29-2019 01:18 AM

After about a week of using this revised method, I will not be modifying the B timing any longer. The overruns posted work fantastic for a nice burble.

Songha 04-08-2019 11:09 PM

Pops were more aggressive having ran this revised tune.

And my buddy caught me popping flames on his dashcam.

https://youtu.be/ztTL9olO9oQ

Chuckls 04-09-2019 09:52 AM

Funfact. 2nd gear high RPM heavy throttle. Release throttle and then immediately tap it for ultimate rapidfire.

FR_STEEZ 04-28-2019 09:49 PM

I just want to backfire on upshifts when banging gears. my buddies brz does it and he only has base b at -10..... I tuned my car the same way and it doesn't happen for me. I dont understand lol. we have the same exhaust mods as well

erebuswarrior 04-28-2019 10:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FR_STEEZ (Post 3212483)
I just want to backfire on upshifts when banging gears. my buddies brz does it and he only has base b at -10..... I tuned my car the same way and it doesn't happen for me. I dont understand lol. we have the same exhaust mods as well

Different drivers. You and him maybe managing clutch and accelerator pedal differently. Have him try it in your car. If he does it easy in your car then it's because of how he's using the accelerator when shifting.

trinidadj 05-20-2019 10:53 AM

I'm on the V4 e85 stage 2+ with catless headers, catless front pipe and a catback exhaust. If I want to make pops and some small flames, do I just need to make the edits from the original post by erebuswarrior?

Hadalet 05-29-2019 08:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elBarto (Post 3198718)
If you want even more control, you can rescale that table to get more rpm's
It's basicly grouping all of the same values in to one table to gain 3 more tables.

http://i66.tinypic.com/2z4fq75.png
(These are settings for a daily driver, just some light added burble)

Can you give a little context? It sounds like what I've been looking for. Just a bump up of the burble that's already there. This is what I see.https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...c5bbdbd0e7.jpg

Sent from my SM-G892A using Tapatalk

elBarto 05-30-2019 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hadalet (Post 3222809)
Can you give a little context? It sounds like what I've been looking for. Just a bump up of the burble that's already there. This is what I see.https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/201...c5bbdbd0e7.jpg

Sent from my SM-G892A using Tapatalk

DO NOT EDIT those tables. You have an incorrect definition!
Editing these will result in a bricked ECU.

Use this updated definition (Only use for V4 roms, do not use these for older V2 tunes)
Those tables are included, then you will see the same as my screenshot.

OFT V4 A00C

erebuswarrior 05-30-2019 11:23 AM

After rescaling the in gear tables, to only have negative timing 2500 RPM and up, I also moved to -15.8, and here's a video of the fire I didn't know I was shooting lol.

https://youtu.be/PBUcT3WOdF0

phiflyhigh 07-09-2019 07:25 PM

So I'm testing this tune out on my 17' BRZ and it works fine. My question though is, can you send me an instruction for how to rescale the mapping for higher RPMs? I don't like the constant burbling/popping at lower RPMs

elBarto 07-10-2019 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by phiflyhigh (Post 3235232)
So I'm testing this tune out on my 17' BRZ and it works fine. My question though is, can you send me an instruction for how to rescale the mapping for higher RPMs? I don't like the constant burbling/popping at lower RPMs

Rescale that table to get more rpm's
It's basicly grouping all of the same values in to one table to gain 3 more tables.

https://images2.imgbox.com/02/db/HyGdbskr_o.png

You can edit the top row with the rpm's also, just copy my table and add your own values. My values are for a daily driver with some very light burbles.

phiflyhigh 07-12-2019 05:53 PM

Thanks ElBarto! I just adjusted mine similar to what you have yours as I don't want all the bangs all the time.

erebuswarrior 07-14-2019 08:54 PM

1 Attachment(s)
This is my rescaled version on Ecutek.
https://youtu.be/PBUcT3WOdF0

BRZ_Mobin17 02-24-2021 08:32 AM

I cant see the rescaled table for higher RPMs. Can anyone repost please? I just want pops and flames from like 3500 - 6500 rpm. I also am boosted with Vortech, but I dont think that will affect this.

elBarto 02-24-2021 05:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BRZ_Mobin17 (Post 3408952)
I cant see the rescaled table for higher RPMs. Can anyone repost please? I just want pops and flames from like 3500 - 6500 rpm. I also am boosted with Vortech, but I dont think that will affect this.

The more negative you go, the "better" the effect will be, going more positive the effect will be more softer.
My temps are in Celsius (left values of 70 and 80), but doesn't matter for the timings

https://images2.imgbox.com/5d/aa/sVognHXo_o.png

BRZ_Mobin17 02-24-2021 09:20 PM

Also a Side question for anyone with the answer. Where the hell do I get the updated Brz template for the OFT?!? Is it a file someone can email me
or do I have to put a request to openflash for it? Thank you in advance.

BRZ_Mobin17 02-24-2021 10:45 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Here's my tables, how does this look?
I'm running vortech and on E85.

elBarto 02-25-2021 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BRZ_Mobin17 (Post 3409184)
Also a Side question for anyone with the answer. Where the hell do I get the updated Brz template for the OFT?!? Is it a file someone can email me
or do I have to put a request to openflash for it? Thank you in advance.

You can find the template files Here

Can't help you with the Vortech/E85 question.
Adding aftermarket forced induction is illegal and E85 is non-existing in my country.

BRZ_Mobin17 02-25-2021 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elBarto (Post 3409399)
You can find the template files Here

Can't help you with the Vortech/E85 question.
Adding aftermarket forced induction is illegal and E85 is non-existing in my country.

I believe that is just a universal template. There is a template that has a photo of the FRS/Brz rather then the Ferrari. And I believe the buttons look a bit different. And no E85? That's a shame.

elBarto 02-26-2021 01:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BRZ_Mobin17 (Post 3409402)
I believe that is just a universal template. There is a template that has a photo of the FRS/Brz rather then the Ferrari. And I believe the buttons look a bit different. And no E85? That's a shame.

The last template with a FRS background was from 2015/2016.
It was changed to the Ferrari for all supported cars.

BRZ_Mobin17 02-27-2021 01:05 AM

Oh, I was way off. Thank you.

After reading that some people will tune their Idle control valve to stay open on overrun for a more desirable flame or pop. I've been looking thru tables on RomRaider, I cant find a way to use the idle valve on overrun but I found some tables for Mass Air Flow which will leave the throttle plate angle more open on decel. I'm assuming this will have the same affect. And possibly not have to play with Pedal to get pops this way.
Does anyone have any input on this idea?

lightning 03-05-2021 04:40 PM

1 Attachment(s)
I tried changing the MAF desired overrun A table this morning. I applied a multiplier on everything from 2000rpm/ 158 degrees on up. I tried 1.1x then went back to 1.05x. It does keep the throttle plate slightly open, but it doesn't keep the injectors on so you still need to do the overrun fueling thing or feather the pedal. So you end up with slightly less engine braking and in my case longer lasting and quieter crackles and pops. I don't know how I feel about the change in engine braking, but I like the change to the sound enough to run it for a while. This is with an OTS E85 tune, catless header and frontpipe, and a stock catback. The rest of my settings are below.

nerve86 06-07-2022 09:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by erebuswarrior (Post 3236993)
This is my rescaled version on Ecutek.
https://youtu.be/PBUcT3WOdF0

I edited this map on ecutek but nothing worked.
Mine is a manual, 98 petrol.

andee 02-25-2023 07:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by erebuswarrior (Post 3115351)
After tuning for quite a few CALID's of the 86 community I now have a better understanding of my version of pops and bangs. You'll want to edit mainly 3 things. Overrun Enrich RPM Delta: This is the amount of RPM drop that needs to happen for Overrun to start. (I use -1, change to whatever RPM you want it to drop by before engaging enrichment) Overrun Initial Injector Enrichment Pulsewidth (I have used anywhere from 0.8 up to 8.8ms) and Base Timing Idle In-Gear Above Speed Threshold (So far in the 176 coolant temp row, -12.97 at 1500RPM to 1800RPM seems to be the right amount of timing for pops/bangs and for those with catless setups, fire.) Make sure you use the fixed xml definition files that are here on the forums for v4.03 OFT tunes. There are some xml files provided by OFT that may not have been fixed yet, that have errors in it, and it will make the In Gear Above Speed Threshold table look way different then it should be.

For those who have issues with throttle delay, either use Pulsewidth's closer to 0.0 or turn it off completely. Long pulse width's like 8.8ms can cause issues with throttle delay especially after lots of pops, but you need to give it some time for fuel trims and the accelerator pedal deadspace to go away. It takes about 50-100 miles of driving in closed loop learning mode before fuel trims settle and throttle dead space goes away. After at least 100 miles of driving, it should be much easier to rev match and throttle delay should not be as much. There will inherently be some delay afterwards and this is because it is using negative timing and a richer mixture at the exhaust cycle. You can't make power with negative timing, only with advanced timing. There are tradeoff's of course, and this is why there's the jerkiness with the traditional B-Timing table pops, since that table directly influences power. In Gear Timing tables luckily don't cause jerkiness on/off throttle. If you can't get used to pressing in the accelerator pedal more for rev matching or the throttle delay is too much, then don't use overrun, just In Gear Timing.

CALID's that aren't compatible are pretty much all Auto trans versions. If you make these changes on a auto trans version, autorev matching when using paddle shifters or gear shifter in manual mode, will NOT work. This is because the auto trans ecm gets confused by the negative timing with In Gear table. Manual users shouldn't be affected by this.

Ecutek users:
I currently have Ecutek RaceRom v9 and using Ecutek's autorev match function on manual with In Gear Above Speed Threshold negative timing, DOES work. So Ecutek users can use the same method on manual trans. I have yet to test on Ecutek with auto trans.
There is only 1 Overrun table in Ecutek, and it is for injector's kicking back on at certain RPM's. There are none of the Overrun tables you see below in Ecutek unfortunately.

Link to, how to fix xml file's.
http://www.ft86club.com/forums/showthread.php?t=126180

I'm on Ecutek and when I want to run afterfire this is my rescaled table on Ecutek.

are these maps now working? I have a 2013 frs and i put a pop tune from 93 oct onto the e85 map, ive been letting it learn so far, but so far no pops at all, is this what this adjustment is for?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:17 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Lite) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2026 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.


Garage vBulletin Plugins by Drive Thru Online, Inc.